
Having Own Yardstick
1. When watching Japanese videos and television programs, I often come across economists making completely opposite arguments. Some say that the government needs to maintain fiscal discipline, while others argue that the government should increase fiscal spending and investment in order to promote economic growth.
As someone who is not an expert in economics, I have long wondered why people who are all categorized as “economists” can hold completely opposing views, and which side is actually right.
2. At one point, I came to realize that economists tend to belong to different schools of thought depending on their professional backgrounds and career experiences.
I also noticed that economists who emphasize fiscal discipline tend to appear frequently in the mainstream media, while some economists who express their views on platforms such as YouTube advocate fiscal expansion.
I then began to understand that behind these differences are, broadly speaking, economists who look at the economy mainly from the perspective of whether the stock market will become more active, and those who look at it mainly from the perspective of whether the bond market might collapse. I also learned that economists with backgrounds in government ministries and agencies tend, for the most part, to emphasize fiscal discipline.
Once I realized that I needed to consider economists’ professional backgrounds when evaluating their arguments, my perspective became somewhat broader.
3. I then realized that, in order to assess the situation accurately, I needed to map economists. So, on paper, I began thinking about two axes that could be used to classify them. I also explored these two axes through dialogue with AI.
There are probably many other possible ways of constructing such axes, depending on how one chooses to look at the issue. One example, however, would be to place on the horizontal axis whether an economist places greater emphasis on the bond market or the stock market, and on the vertical axis whether the institutional background in which the economist received his or her professional training was the government or the private sector.
I thought that using these X and Y axes might provide a useful way of classifying economists and their arguments.
This is, of course, not intended as a rigorous classification of economists, but rather as a simple mental map that helps me understand where different arguments may be coming from.

4. When I actually tried doing this, I found that economists’ arguments could be classified quite clearly, providing useful material for my own thinking and for forming judgments about economic and fiscal policy.
Which argument is correct may vary depending on the circumstances of the particular period. Conversely, however, if we do not have such a two-axis map in our own minds, we may simply accept the arguments of economists selected to appear on television programs or videos that have their own intentions or agendas. As a result, we may end up internalizing concepts that reflect someone else’s intentions.
We may then come to believe that Japan needs greater fiscal discipline, or, alternatively, that Japan has more room to increase fiscal spending.
The essential point is that it is important to have this kind of yardstick within ourselves. Yet it seems to me that the importance of developing such a yardstick is not very widely recognized.
5. Of course, developing our own yardstick is probably not something we can achieve simply by watching television programs or videos.
We need to explore and learn for ourselves, think through trial and error, develop hypotheses from that process, and repeatedly test those hypotheses. Through this process, our own axes of judgment gradually begin to take shape.
Perhaps SME owners also need this kind of thinking exercise from time to time. Even business owners who already practice this kind of thinking on their own may discover new hypotheses or possible solutions by occasionally exploring issues together with a group of other people.
These were the thoughts that occupied my mind today.