
ãããŒã«ãŒÃã²ãŒã çè«ãGTOã®ãåè¡¡ããšã¯äœãïŒå ¬åŒã®äžžæèšããè±åŽããAKQã²ãŒã å ¥é
ããŒã«ãŒã®åº§åŠãé²ãããšããBetãµã€ãºãååãªãçžæã®ã³ãŒã«çã¯75%ïŒMDFïŒãããããã®å€§ããã«åãããŠãã©ãé »åºŠãæ±ºããããšãã£ãå ¬åŒãæ°åã«ããããåºäŒããŸãã
ããããããªããã®æ°åã«ãªãã®ãïŒããšèããããšã¯ããã§ããããã
ãçžæãç¡å·®å¥ã«ãããããã«ãã®é »åºŠã§æã€ããšãã説æãããè³ã«ããŸãããå®ã¯ããã¯çµæã®è©±ã§ãããæ¬è³ªçãªåºçºç¹ã§ã¯ãããŸããã
ããŒã«ãŒã«ãããGTOïŒGame Theory OptimalïŒã²ãŒã çè«çæé©æŠç¥ïŒã®æ ¹æ¬ã«ããã®ã¯ããšãŠãã·ã³ãã«ãªååã§ãã
ãäºãã«ãèªåã®æã¡æïŒã¬ã³ãžïŒå šäœã®EVïŒæåŸ å€ïŒãæå€§åããã
ããŒã«ãŒã¯2人ã§è¡ããŒããµã ã²ãŒã ïŒäžæ¹ã®å©çã仿¹ã®æå€±ã«ãªãã²ãŒã ïŒã§ãããã®ããããèªåã®EVãæå€§åããããšããããšã¯ãçžæã®EVãæå°åãããããšãšå矩ã«ãªããŸãã
ã€ãŸãããã¬ã€ã€ãŒåå£«ã®æ»é²ã¯ã
ãèªåã®ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVãæå€§åãããåŽã
ãçžæã®ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVãæå°åãããåŽã
ã®æŠããšããŠæããããšãã§ããŸãã
ãã®èšäºã§ã¯ãæãã·ã³ãã«ãªãAKQã²ãŒã ããšããã¢ãã«ã䜿ããäž¡è ãèªèº«ã®EVïŒæåŸ å€ïŒãæé©åããããšããçµæãšããŠãåè¡¡ããå°ãããããã»ã¹ãã髿 ¡æ°åŠã¬ãã«ã®åŒã§è§£ãæãããŸãã
1. ä»åæ±ããAKQã²ãŒã ãã®èšå®
ãŸãã¯ãèããã²ãŒã ã®ã«ãŒã«ãã·ã³ãã«ã«æŽçããŸãã
ã²ãŒã ã®åºæ¬ã«ãŒã«
ãããã®å€§ããïŒP
Betãµã€ãºïŒB
ã«ãŒãã®åŒ·ãïŒA> K> Q
ãã¬ã€ã€ãŒïŒIPïŒåŸãã§ã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã人ïŒãš OOPïŒå ã«è¡åãã人ïŒ
ã«ãŒãã®é åïŒ
IP 㯠Aãš Qã 50% ãã€æã£ãŠãã
OOP ã¯åžžã«Kãæã£ãŠãã
ã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã®æµã
OOP ã¯æåã«å¿ ã Check ããŸãã
IP 㯠Bet ã Check ãéžã³ãŸãïŒRaiseã¯ãããŸããïŒã
IPãBetããå ŽåãOOP 㯠Call ã Fold ãéžã³ãŸãã
ããã³ãæ§æãšåŒ·ãã
IP : Â [ A (50%) ] Â > Â OOP : [ K (100%) ] Â > Â IP : [ Q (50%) ]
ãªãOOPã¯æåã«Checkããå§ããŠããã®ãïŒ
ãOOPãæåããBetã§ããã®ã§ã¯ïŒããšæããããããŸãããããããOOPã®æã¡æã¯åžžã«äžé匷床㮠Kã§ãã
OOPãBetããŠããŸããšãåã£ãŠãã匷ããã³ãAã ãã«CallïŒãŸãã¯RaiseïŒãããè² ããŠãã匱ããã³ãQã«ã¯ Fold ãããŠããŸããŸããã€ãŸããBetããŠãåŸããããšããªããããOOPã¯å¿ ãCheckããèããã®ãæåãšãªããŸãïŒæ¬é¡ããéžããªããããããã¯åæãšããŠé²ããŸãïŒã
2. ãã¬ã€ã€ãŒãéžã¹ã倿°ã¯ããã£ã2ã€ã
äžèŠè€éã«èŠããããŒã«ãŒã§ããããã®ã²ãŒã ã§ãã¬ã€ã€ãŒãèªç±ã«ã³ã³ãããŒã«ã§ããæ°åã¯ãã£ã2ã€ãããããŸããã
ãŸããIPã®ç«å ŽããèããŠã¿ãŸãããã
IPãæã€ Aã¯çµ¶å¯Ÿã«åãŠãæåŒ·ã«ãŒãïŒãããïŒãªã®ã§ãåžžã«Betããã®ãæåã§ãïŒCheckããçç±ã¯äœããããŸããïŒã
ãããã£ãŠã決ããã¹ã倿°ã¯ä»¥äžã®2ã€ã ãã«ãªããŸãã
qïŒIPãQïŒãã©ãïŒã§Betããé »åºŠïŒ0âŠqâŠ1ïŒ
ïœïŒOOPã ã§Callããé »åºŠïŒ0âŠkâŠ1ïŒ
IP㯠q ã調æŽããŠèªèº«ã®å©çãå¢ããããšããOOP㯠k ã調æŽããŠIPã®å©çãåãããšããŸãã
3. æéèŠïŒIPã®ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVïŒæåŸ å€ïŒãåŒã«ãã
ã§ã¯ããããããæ¬é¡ã§ããåã ã®ãã³ãã§ã¯ãªããIPã®ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVãèããŸãã
IPã¯A ã 50%ãQ ã 50%æã£ãŠããã®ã§ãIPå
šäœã®EVã¯æ¬¡ã®ããã«ãªããŸãã
ããããã®ãã³ãã®EVãèšç®ããŠã¿ãŸãããã
â EV(A)ã®èšç®
Aã¯å¿ ãBetããŸãã
OOPã FoldïŒç¢ºç1-kïŒãããšãããã P ãç²åŸããŸãã
OOPã CallïŒç¢ºçkïŒãããšãçžæãã远å ã§ B ã奪ããã®ã§ P+B ãç²åŸããŸãã
ãã£ãŠã
â¡ EV(Q)$ã®èšç®
Q ã¯é »åºŠ q ã§Betããæ®ã 1-q ã®é »åºŠã§CheckããŸãã
Checkããå Žåã¯å¿ ãè² ããã®ã§å©åŸã¯ 0 ã§ãã
Betããå ŽåïŒç¢ºç qïŒïŒ
OOPã FoldïŒç¢ºç 1-kïŒããã°ããã©ãæåã§ããã P ãç²åŸããŸãã
OOPã CallïŒç¢ºç kïŒããã°ãèŠç Žãã㊠Beté¡ B ã倱ããŸãã
ãã£ãŠã
⢠ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVïŒäžå¿ãšãªãåŒïŒ
ããããåäœããããšãIPã®ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVã¯æ¬¡ã®ããã«æžããŸãã
æ¬åŒ§ã®äžãæŽçããŠã¿ãŸãããã
ãã®åŒããæ¬èšäºã§æãéèŠãªåŒã§ãã
IPãšOOPã®æçã¯ãã¹ãŠãã®äžã€ã®åŒã§è¡šãããŠããŸãã
4. IPåŽã®æé©åïŒOOPã®Callé »åºŠã«å¿ããŠã©ãåããïŒ
ãŸãã¯ãOOPã®Callé »åºŠ k ãåºå®ãããšãã«ãIPãèªèº«ã®EVãæå€§åããããã«ãã©ãé »åºŠ qãã©ãéžã¶ã¹ãããèããŸãã
å ã»ã©ã®åŒã§ãq ã«çç®ããŠã¿ãŸãã
ãã®åŒã®äžã§ãq ã«æãã£ãŠããä¿æ°ã¯ P - k(P+B) ã§ãã
IP㯠EV(IP) ãã§ããã ã倧ãããããã®ã§ããã®ä¿æ°ã®ãæ£è² ãã«ãã£ãŠæé©ãª q ã®éžæãå€ãããŸãã
ã±ãŒã¹1ïŒP - k(P+B) > 0 ã®ãšã
q ã®ä¿æ°ããã©ã¹ãªã®ã§ãq ã倧ããïŒæå€§å€ã® q=1 ã«ïŒããã»ã© EV(IP) ã¯é«ããªããŸãã
çŽæçã«èšãã°ããOOPãCallããªããããŠããïŒk ãå°ããïŒã®ã§ãIP㯠Q ã100%ãã©ãããæ¹ãåŸã ãšããç¶æ ã§ãã
ã±ãŒã¹2ïŒP - k(P+B) < 0 ã®ãšã
q ã®ä¿æ°ããã€ãã¹ãªã®ã§ãq ãå°ããïŒæå°å€ã® q=0 ã«ïŒããã»ã© EV(IP) ã¯é«ããªããŸãã
çŽæçã«èšãã°ããOOPãCallããããŠããïŒ$k$ ã倧ããïŒã®ã§ãIP㯠Qã§ãã©ããäžåæããªãïŒ0%ïŒæ¹ãåŸã ãšããç¶æ ã§ãã
å¢çç¹ïŒåãæ¿ããã®åå²ç¹ïŒ
ãã©ããå¢ããã¹ããæžããã¹ããã®å¢çç·ã¯ãä¿æ°ãã¡ããã© 0 ã«ãªããšãã§ãã
ããã $k$ ã«ã€ããŠè§£ããšã次ãåŸãããŸãã
ãã® k*ã®å€ããããäžè¬ã«ããŒã«ãŒçšèªã§åŒã°ãã MDFïŒMinimum Defense FrequencyïŒæäœé²è¡é »åºŠïŒ ã®æ£äœã§ãã åã«ãå®ãã¹ãå²åã®å ¬åŒããšããŠæèšãããã¡ã§ããããã®å®æ ã¯ãçžæã®ãã©ãã®EV墿žããã©ã¹ãããã€ãã¹ãžãšå ¥ãæ¿ããåãæ¿ãç¹ãã«éããªãããšãåãããŸãã(MDFã«ã€ããŠã¯åŸã§ã説æ)
5. OOPåŽã®æé©åïŒIPã®ãã©ãé »åºŠã«å¿ããŠã©ãåããïŒ
次ã«ãIPã®ãã©ãé »åºŠ $q$ ãåºå®ãããšãã«ãOOPãçžæã®EVãæå°åïŒïŒèªåã®æå€±ãæå°åïŒããããã« k ãã©ãéžã¶ã¹ãããèããŸãã
å ã»ã©ã® EV(IP)ã®åŒããä»åºŠã¯ k ã«ã€ããŠæŽçãçŽããŠã¿ãŸãã
OOPã¯ããŒã«ãŒããŒããµã ã²ãŒã ã§ãããããIPã®EVãã§ããã ãå°ããããããã¬ã€ã€ãŒã§ãã
ãã®ãããk ã«æãã£ãŠããä¿æ° B - q(P+B) ã®æ£è² ã«ãã£ãŠæé©ãª k ãæ±ºãŸããŸãã
ã±ãŒã¹1ïŒB - q(P+B) > 0 ã®ãšã
k ã®ä¿æ°ããã©ã¹ã§ããOOPã k ãå¢ãããšIPã®EVãäžããŠïŒïŒèªåã¯æãããŠïŒããŸããããOOPã¯CallããããããŸãããæå°å€ã® k=0ïŒ100% FoldïŒãéžã³ãŸãã
çŽæçã«èšãã°ããIPã®ãã©ããå°ãªãããïŒq ãå°ããïŒã®ã§ãOOPã¯Callããã ãæã ãšããç¶æ ã§ãã
ã±ãŒã¹2ïŒB - q(P+B) < 0 ã®ãšã
k ã®ä¿æ°ããã€ãã¹ã§ããOOPã k ãå¢ããã»ã©IPã®EVãäžããããïŒïŒèªåã®æå€±ãæžãããïŒãããæå€§å€ã® k=1ïŒ100% CallïŒãéžã³ãŸãã
çŽæçã«èšãã°ããIPããã©ãããããŠããïŒq ã倧ããïŒã®ã§ãOOPã¯å šéšCallããŠåããæ¹ãåŸã ãšããç¶æ ã§ãã
å¢çç¹ïŒåãæ¿ããã®åå²ç¹ïŒ
Callãã¹ããFoldãã¹ããã®å¢çç·ã¯ãä¿æ°ã 0ã«ãªããšãã§ãã
ããã $q$ ã«ã€ããŠè§£ããšã次ãåŸãããŸãã
ãã® q*ã®å€ã¯ããŒã«ãŒã«ããã æé©ããªã¥ãŒã»ãã©ãæ¯çïŒVBæ¯ïŒ ã®ãã©ãéšåã«çžåœããŸãã ããããµã€ãºã«å¯ŸããBetãµã€ãº B ã®å²åã«ãã£ãŠãçžæã®Callã®EV墿žãå ¥ãæ¿ããåãæ¿ãç¹ããèšç®ããçµæãããã®æ¯çãªã®ã§ãã
6. åè¡¡æŠç¥ã®æç«ïŒNash EquilibriumïŒ
ãããŸã§ã®äž¡è ã®ååãæŽçããŠã¿ãŸãããã
OOPãCallãæžããã°ãIPã¯ãã©ããå¢ãã
IPããã©ããå¢ããã°ãOOPã¯Callãå¢ãã
OOPãCallãå¢ããã°ãIPã¯ãã©ããæžãã
IPããã©ããæžããã°ãOOPã¯Callãæžãã
ãã®ããã«ããäºãããçžæã®æŠç¥ã«å¯ŸããŠããåŸãªã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ããžäžæ¹çã«ä¿®æ£ããããšãããšãæŠç¥ããããããšåŸªç°ããŠããŸããŸãã
ããããå¯äžããäºãã«æŠç¥ãå€ããåæ©ãå®å šã«ãªããªãç¹ããååšããŸãã
ããããäž¡è ã®å¢çç·ãåæã«æãç«ã€ä»¥äžã®ãã€ã³ãã§ãã
ãã®çµã¿åãã ã®ç¶æ ã«ãããšãïŒ
IPã¯ãã©ãé »åºŠ q ãå€ããŠãEVãæ¹åããŸããã
OOPãCallé »åºŠ k ãå€ããŠãIPã®EVãããã«äžããããšã¯ã§ããŸããã
ããäºãã«èªåã ãäžæ¹çã«æŠç¥ã倿ŽããŠãåŸãããªãäžç¹ãââããããããã²ãŒã çè«ã«ããããããã·ã¥åè¡¡ïŒGTOæŠç¥ïŒãã®æ£äœã§ãã
7. ãç¡å·®å¥æ¡ä»¶ãã¯æé©åã®ãçµæããšããŠçŸãã
ããã§ãããããããŒã«ãŒã®è§£èª¬æ¬ãªã©ã§ããç®ã«ãããç¡å·®å¥ïŒIndifferenceïŒããšããæŠå¿µã«è¿œãã€ããŸãã
å°ãããåè¡¡ç¹ k* = P/(P+B) ããIPã® QïŒãã©ããã³ãïŒã®EVåŒã«ä»£å ¥ããŠã¿ãŸãããã
äžæ¹ãQ ã§Checkããå Žåã®EVãåœç¶ $0$ ã§ãã
ã€ãŸããåè¡¡ç¹ã«ãããŠã¯ ãIP㯠Q ã§BetããŠãCheckããŠãå©åŸãåãïŒç¡å·®å¥ïŒã«ãªãã ã®ã§ãã
åãããã«ãåè¡¡ç¹ q* = B/(P+B) ã«ãããŠã¯ãOOPã® K ã ãCallããŠãFoldããŠãå©åŸãåãïŒç¡å·®å¥ïŒã ã«ãªã£ãŠããŸãã
ããã§éåžžã«éèŠãªå æé¢ä¿ã確èªããŠãããŸãããã
à ééãïŒãããã誀解ïŒïŒ
ãçžæãç¡å·®å¥ã«ããããã«ããã®ãã©ãé »åºŠãã³ãŒã«é »åºŠã決ããã⯠æ£ããçè§£ïŒ
ãäž¡è ãã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVãæé©åïŒæå€§åã»æå°åïŒãåã£ãçµæãšããŠãå¢çç·äžã«ãããã³ãã®ã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã®EVãçããïŒç¡å·®å¥ã«ïŒãªãã
é åºãšããŠã¯ããããŸã§ãã¬ã³ãžEVã®æé©åããåå ã§ããããåã ã®ãã³ãã®ç¡å·®å¥ãã¯çµæãªã®ã§ãã
8. ãŸãšãïŒGTOåŠç¿ã§æ¬åœã«å€§åãªããš
GTOãçè«ãåŠãã§ãããšã
ããããã®50%Betã«å¯ŸããMDF㯠66.7%ã
ããã®ã©ã€ã³ã§ã®ãã©ããšããªã¥ãŒã®æ¯ç㯠1:2ã
ãšãã£ããæ°å€ãããå ¬åŒãã®æèšã«çµå§ããŠããŸããã¡ã§ãã
ãããããããã®æ°å€ã¯ã©ããããšããªãéããŠããéæ³ã®å ¬åŒã§ã¯ãããŸããã
ä»åèŠãŠããããã«ã
IPã¯ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVãæå€§åããã
OOPã¯ãããæå°åããã
ãäºããæåãå°œãããçµæãæŠç¥ãåè¡¡ãã
ãšããéåžžã«åçŽã§çŸããæ°åŠçæé©ååé¡ããèªç¶ã«å°ãåºããããã®ã§ãã
GTOãšã¯ãåã ã®ãã³ãã«å¯Ÿãããæèšãã¹ãæ£è§£ã®æé ãªã¹ããã§ã¯ãããŸããã
ããäºãã®æã¡æïŒã¬ã³ãžïŒå šäœããæåŸ å€ã远æ±ãåã£ãæ«ã«è¡ãçã調åã®ç¶æ ã ã®ããšãæãã®ã§ãã
ãã®ãã¬ã³ãžEVã®æé©åããšããèŠç¹ãæã€ããšã§ã宿Šã§æªç¥ã®ã·ãã¥ãšãŒã·ã§ã³ã«çŽé¢ããéã«ããåãªãæ°åã®äžžæèšãè¶ ããæ¬è³ªçãªãã¬ã€å€æãã§ããããã«ãªãã¯ãã§ãã
宿Šã®ããŒã«ãŒãšAKQã²ãŒã ã®éã
ãããŸã§ã¯ã話ãåçŽã«ããããã«ãAKQã²ãŒã ããšããæ¥µéãŸã§åãèœãšããã¢ãã«ã䜿ã£ãŠããŸããã
宿Šã®ããŒã«ãŒïŒãªããŒãã¿ãŒã³ã§ã®è€éãªã¬ã³ãžåå£«ã®æŠãïŒã§ã¯ããã®ã¢ãã«ããããã«ããã€ãã®éèŠãªèŠçŽ ãå€åããŸãã
1. ãã©ããã³ãã®EVãããŒããã«ãªããšã¯éããªã
AKQã²ãŒã ã® QïŒçŽç²ãªãããããã ïŒã¯ãCheckãããåç0%ã»EVã0ã§ããã
ããã宿Šã§ã¯ãCheckããŠãçžæã®ããã«åŒ±ããã³ãã«åã£ãŠãããïŒã·ã§ãŒããŠã³ããªã¥ãŒãããïŒãåŸã®ã¹ããªãŒãã§é転ããå¯èœæ§ïŒããã¯ãã¢ããããŒãªã©ã®ãšã¯ã€ãã£ïŒãæ®ã£ãŠãããããŸãã
ãã®ããããCheckã®EVããã©ã¹ãã§ããã±ãŒã¹ãå€ããããã©ããæã¡ããããšãCheckã§ååã§ããã¯ãã®EVïŒShowdown Value / EquityïŒãèªãæšãŠãŠããŸãããšããã€ã³ã»ã³ãã£ããåãããã©ãé »åºŠã«èªç¶ãªãã¬ãŒããããããŸãã
2. åçãã100% or 0%ãã§ã¯ãªãïŒãšã¯ã€ãã£ã®ååšïŒ
AKQã²ãŒã ã§ã¯ A ã¯çµ¶å¯Ÿåå©ïŒ100%ïŒãQ ã¯çµ¶å¯ŸæåïŒ0%ïŒã§ããã
宿Šã§ã¯ã60%åãŠããã³ããã30%åãŠããã³ãããšãã£ãã°ã©ããŒã·ã§ã³ãååšããŸããçžæã«CallããããšããŠãäžå®ã®ç¢ºçã§åãŠãïŒãããã¯FoldãããŠãçžæã®ãšã¯ã€ãã£ã奪ããïŒãããåãªãMDFïŒMinimum Defense FrequencyïŒã®æ°åŒã ãã§å®ååŽã»æ»æåŽã®æé©é »åºŠã決ãŸãããã§ã¯ãããŸããã
3. 宿Šã§ã¯ãMDFãå®ããªããã®ããããåè¡¡æŠç¥ã«ãªã
AKQã²ãŒã ã§ã¯ãOOPã®Callé »åºŠ k* ã¯çµæçã«MDF=P/(P+BïŒãšäžèŽããŸããã
ãããäžèšã®ãããªããšã¯ã€ãã£ã®ååšããããã©ã©ã€ãºïŒã³ã³ãã³ã¹ãã®ã¬ã³ãžæ§é ã®éããããã宿Šã§ã¯ãDefenceåŽãMDFéãã«å®ããšéå°é²è¡ïŒOver-defendïŒã«ãªããEVãèœãšãã±ãŒã¹ãå€ã ãããŸãã
GTOãœã«ããŒã®è§£æã§ãMDFãããããªãFoldãããã®ãæé©è§£ã«ãªãã®ã¯ããŸãã«ãã®ã¬ã³ãžå šäœã®EVæé©åãåããŠããããã§ãã
