1. ã¯ããã«
以åã®èšäºã§ã¯ãããžãã¹ã«ãããæœçã®å¹ææ€èšŒã®æ¹æ³ãšããŠãå·®åã®å·®åæ³ãšããå ææšè«ã®ææ³ã«ã€ããŠç޹ä»ããŸãããä»åã®èšäºã§ã¯ãããïŒã€ã®å ææšè«ã®ææ³ã§ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«ããåææ³ã玹ä»ããŸãã
åèæç®ïŒã§ãåãäžããããŠããã·ãã¥ãšãŒã·ã§ã³ãèããŠã¿ãŸããããããã¹ããã²ãŒã ã®å€§æäŒç€Ÿããã¢ããªã®å©çšãä¿é²ãããããèªç€Ÿã¹ããã²ãŒã ã®TVCMã2é±éæŸéããŸãããTVCMæŸéçµäºåŸãTVCMã«ãã£ãŠã¢ããªã®å©çšç¶æ³ãã©ã®çšåºŠæ¹åããããæž¬ãã«ã¯ã©ã®ãããªæ€èšŒãããã°ããã§ããããã
åçŽã«ã¯ãTVCMæŸéåŸã®ã¢ããªå©çšç¶æ³ã®ããŒã¿ãçšãããTVCMãèŠããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéããšãTVCMãèŠãªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéãã®å·®åãèšç®ãããããTVCMæœçã®å¹æãšèŠåãæ¹æ³ãèããããŸããããããTVCMãèŠããŠãŒã¶ãŒãšèŠãªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã§ã¯ã幎霢局ãçæŽ»ã¹ã¿ã€ã«ãç°ãªããããå
çšã®å·®åã«ã¯TVCMãèŠããã©ãã以å€ã®èŠå ã«ãã圱é¿ãå«ãŸããTVCMæœçã®å¹æãããŸãæšå®ã§ããªãå ŽåããããŸããäŸãã°ãè¥ã人ã®TVé¢ããèãããšãTVãèŠãã®ã¯å¹Žéœ¢å±€ãæ¯èŒçé«ã人ãã¡ã§ãããšäºæ³ãã§ãããã®ãããªäººãã¡ã¯å
ã
ã¹ããã²ãŒã ã®å©çšæéã¯æ¯èŒçå°ãªããããããŸããïŒå³1ïŒã
ãã®ãããªç¶æ³ã§ãTVCMãèŠããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéãšãèŠãªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéã®åçŽãªå·®åããšã£ãŠããŸããšãæ¬æ¥æšå®ãããæœç广ãšã¯ç°ãªãéãæšå®ããŠããŸãæãããããŸãããã®ãããªåé¡ããã»ã¬ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã€ã¢ã¹ïŒéžæãã€ã¢ã¹ïŒãšãããŸãã
ä»å玹ä»ããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããåææ³ã¯ãTVCMãèŠããŠãŒã¶ãŒå±€ãšèŠãªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒå±€ã®å±æ§ã»è¡åãªã©ã®èæ¯æ
å ±ã®éããèæ
®ããæœç广ãããç²Ÿç·»ã«æšå®ããããã®ææ³ã§ããæ¬¡ç¯ã§ã¯ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããåææ³ã解説ããããã®æºåãšããŠãå ææšè«ã®åºæ¬äºé
ã説æããŸãã

ââââââââââ å³ïŒïŒ TVCMãã¿ããŠãŒã¶ãŒå±€ãšèŠãªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒå±€ã®éã
2. å ææšè«ã®åºæ¬äºé
2-1. çšèªã®å®çŸ©
ããã§ã¯ãå ææšè«ã®çšèªãå®çŸ©ããŸãã
ãŸãããŠãŒã¶ãŒã«TVCMãèŠãŠããããªã©ã®æœçãã¢ã¯ã·ã§ã³ã®ããšãåŠçœ®ãšåŒã³ãŸãããããŠãåŠçœ®ãè¡ã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã°ã«ãŒããåŠçœ®çŸ€ãåŠçœ®ãè¡ããªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã°ã«ãŒãã察ç
§çŸ€ãšãããŸããããã«ãã¢ããªå©çšæéã®ãããªãããžãã¹ã«ãããŠçµæãšãªã倿°ãçµæå€æ°ãšåŒã³ãŸãããŠãŒã¶ãŒ$i$ããšã«åŠçœ®å²ãåœãŠå€æ°$Z_i (i=1,âŠ,N)$ãå°å
¥ãããŠãŒã¶ãŒ$i$ãåŠçœ®ãåããå Žåã¯$Z_i=1$ãåŠçœ®ãåããªãã£ãå Žåã¯$Z_i=0$ãšå²ãæ¯ããŸããæ¬¡ã«ãåãŠãŒã¶ãŒã®åŠçœ®ãåããå Žåã®çµæå€æ°ã$Y_i^{(1)}$ãåŠçœ®ãåããªãã£ãå Žåã®çµæå€æ°ã$Y_i^{(0)}$ãšããŸãã
åãŠãŒã¶ãŒã«$Y_i^{(1)}$ãš$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®äž¡æ¹ãå®çŸ©ããããšã¯éåæããããããããŸãããå®éã«èŠ³æž¬ã§ããçµæå€æ°ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒäŸïŒTVCMãèŠããŠãŒã¶ãŒå±€ïŒã«ã€ããŠã¯$Y_i^{(1)}$ïŒäŸïŒTVCMãèŠãå Žåã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéïŒã®ã¿ã察ç
§çŸ€ïŒäŸïŒTVCMãèŠãªãã£ããŠãŒã¶ãŒå±€ïŒã«ã€ããŠã¯$Y_i^{(0)}$ïŒäŸïŒTVCMãèŠãªãã£ãå Žåã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéïŒã®ã¿ã ããã§ããããããããã§ã¯ã芳枬ãããªãã£ãããäžæ¹ã®çµæå€æ°ããååšã¯ããããã©ãããŸã§èŠ³æž¬ãã§ããªãããšããããã«è§£éããŸãããã®ããã«ãå®éã«ã¯èµ·ãããªãã£ãçµæã«ã€ããŠãå®çŸ©ããæ çµã¿ãã«ãŒãã³ã®å æã¢ãã«ãšåŒã³ãŸãããããã¯ãå®éã«ã¯èµ·ãããªãã£ãæœåšçãªçµæãä»®æ³çã«èããããšãããåå®ä»®æ³ã¢ãã«ãšãåŒã³ãŸãã
ãã®æ çµã¿ã®ããšã§ã芳枬ãããçµæå€æ°$Y_i$ãå®çŸ©ããŸãã$Y_i$ã¯ããŠãŒã¶ãŒ$i$ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã®å Žåã¯$Y_i^{(1)}$ã察ç
§çŸ€ã®å Žåã¯$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®å€ãåããŸãããããã£ãŠã$Y_i$ã¯ä»¥äžã®ããã«è¡šãããšãã§ããŸãã
Y_i = \left\{
\begin{array}{ll}
Y_i^{(1)} & (Z_i = 1) \\
Y_i^{(0)} & (Z_i = 0)
\end{array}
\right.
\tag{1}
æåŸã«ãå ±å€é$X_i$ãå®çŸ©ããŸããå ±å€é$X_i$ã¯åŠçœ®å²ãåœãŠå€æ°$Z_i$ãšçµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(1)}$, $Y_i^{(0)}$ã®äž¡æ¹ã«åœ±é¿ãåãŒã倿°ã®ããšã§ããä»åã®ã·ãã¥ãšãŒã·ã§ã³ã§ã¯ã幎霢ãTVã®èŠèŽæéãªã©ãå ±å€éãšããŠèããããŸãã
以äžã§å®çŸ©ããåŠçœ®å²ãåœãŠå€æ°$Z_i$ãçµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(1)}$, $Y_i^{(0)}$ãããã³èŠ³æž¬ãããçµæå€æ°$Y_i$ã®ããŒã¿äŸã衚ïŒã«ç€ºããŸãããã®è¡šã§ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠããããŠãŒã¶ãŒã¯ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠããããŠãŒã¶ãŒã«æ¯ã¹ãŠçµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(1)}$, $Y_i^{(0)}$ãå°ããåŸåã«ããïŒããããã¢ããªã®å©çšæéãçãåŸåã«ããïŒãšããèšå®ã«ããŠããŸãã以éã§ã¯ããã®è¡šãçšããŠãæœçã®å¹æïŒåŠçœ®å¹æïŒãå®çŸ©ããŠãããŸãã
âââ 衚ïŒïŒ åŠçå²ãåœãŠå€æ°$Z_i$ãçµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(1)}$, $Y_i^{(0)}$ãããã³èŠ³æž¬ãããçµæå€æ°$Y_i$ã®äŸ
âââââââïŒçµæå€æ°$Y$ã¯ã¢ããªå©çšæéïŒç§ïŒãšããŠããŸãïŒ

2-2. å¹³ååŠçœ®å¹æïŒATEïŒã®å®çŸ©
åŠçœ®å¹æãšããŠãŸãèããããã®ã¯ã以äžã§å®çŸ©ãããå¹³ååŠçœ®å¹æïŒAverage Treatment Effect, 以äžATEïŒã§ãã
\tau_{ATE} = E[Y^{(1)}] - E[Y^{(0)}]
ATEã¯ãåãŠãŒã¶ãŒã®çµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(1)}$ïŒäŸïŒTVCMãèŠãå Žåã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéïŒãšçµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(0)}$ïŒäŸïŒTVCMãèŠãªãã£ãå Žåã®ã¢ããªå©çšæéïŒã®ããããã®æåŸ
å€ã®å·®åãšããŠå®çŸ©ãããŸãã
çæ³çã«ã¯ã$\tau_{ATE}$ã®æšå®å€$\hat\tau_{ATE}$ã¯åãŠãŒã¶ãŒå人ã®$Y_i^{(1)}$, $Y_i^{(0)}$ãçšããŠ
\hat{\tau}_{ATE} = \frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^{N}Y_i^{(1)} - \frac{1}{N} \sum_{i=1}^{N}Y_i^{(0)}
ãšããŠèšç®ããããšãã§ããŸãã第äžé ããã³ç¬¬äºé ã¯ãããã衚ïŒã®èµ€è²ã®å®ç·ãããã³éè²ã®å®ç·ã§å²ã£ãéšåã®å¹³åå€ã«çžåœããŸããããããå説ã§èª¬æããããã«ãåãŠãŒã¶ãŒã«å¯ŸããŠã¯$Y_i^{(1)}$ã$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®ã©ã¡ãããã芳枬ã§ããªããããäžèšã®èšç®ã¯ã§ããŸãããããã§ã芳枬ãããããŒã¿ã®ã¿ããã§ã$\tau_{ATE}$ãæšå®ããããã«çšããããæ¹æ³ã®äžã€ããæ¬¡ç¯ã§ç޹ä»ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããåææ³ã§ãã
ããã§ãå°ãèéã«ãããŸãããïŒç¯ã§ç޹ä»ããåçŽãªå·®åã®éèšã§ã¯ã©ã®ãããªå€ãæšå®ããŠããããšã«ãªãããèŠãŠã¿ãŸããããïŒåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããåææ³ã«ãèå³ãããæ¹ã¯ã次ç¯ãŸã§èªã¿é£ã°ããŠããã ããŠæ§ããŸãããïŒ1ç¯ã§ç޹ä»ããæ¹æ³ã§ã¯ã$E[Y^{(1)}]$ã¯åŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=1$ïŒããåŸããã$Y_i^{(1)}$ã®ã¿ã$E[Y^{(0)}]$ã¯å¯Ÿç §çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=0$ïŒããåŸããã$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®ã¿ãéèšããŠç®åºããŠããã®ã§ã
\hat{\tau}_{ATE}^{naive} = \frac{1}{N_1} \sum_{i=1}^{N}Z_i Y_i^{(1)} - \frac{1}{N_0} \sum_{i=1}^{N}(1 - Z_i) Y_i^{(0)}
\tag{2}
ãšè¡šãããšãã§ããŸããããã§ã$N_1=\sum_{i=1}^N {Z_i}$ ã¯åŠçœ®çŸ€ã®ãŠãŒã¶ãŒæ°ã$N_0=\sum_{i=1}^N(1-Z_i)$ã¯å¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã®ãŠãŒã¶ãŒæ°ã§ããããã¯ããããã衚ïŒã®èµ€è²ã®ç¹ç·ãšéè²ã®ç¹ç·ã§å²ã£ãéšåã®å¹³åå€ã®å·®åã衚ããŠããŸããåŒ(2)å³èŸºã®ç¬¬äžé
ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«éå®ãã$Y_i^{(1)}$ã®æåŸ
å€($Z=1$ã§æ¡ä»¶ä»ãã$Y_i^{(1)}$ã®æåŸ
å€$E[Y_i^{(1)}|Z=1]$)ã®æšå®éã第äºé
ã¯å¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã«éå®ãã$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®æåŸ
å€($Z=0$ã§æ¡ä»¶ä»ãã$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®æåŸ
å€$E[Y_i^{(0)} |Z=0]$)ã®æšå®éãšãªã£ãŠããŸããã€ãŸãã$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ã¯$E[Y_i^{(1)}|Z=1]-E[Y_i^{(0)}|Z=0]$ã®æšå®éãšãªã£ãŠããŸã£ãŠããŸãã
衚ïŒãèŠããšãåŠçœ®çŸ€($Z=1$)ã«ã¯å¯Ÿç
§çŸ€($Z=0$)ãšæ¯ã¹$Y_i^{(1)}$ãš$Y_i^{(0)}$ãå°ãããŠãŒã¶ãŒãå€ããçµæãšããŠã$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ã¯æ¬æ¥æšå®ãããé$\tau_{ATE}$ããä¹é¢ããŠããŸãããšãèŠãŠåããŸãã
3. åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããå¹³ååŠçœ®å¹æïŒATEïŒã®æšå®
3-1. åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãšã¯
åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãšã¯ããããµã³ãã«ã®å ±å€é$X$ãäžãããããšãã®ããã®ãµã³ãã«ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠããã確çã§ããã€ãŸããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e$ã¯
e = Pr(Z=1|X)
ãšå®çŸ©ãããŸããTVCMæœçã®å¹ææ€èšŒã®äŸã§ãããšã幎霢局ãé«ããTVèŠèŽæéãé·ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã¯ãåŠçœ®ãåããïŒTVCMãèŠãïŒå¯èœæ§ãé«ããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã¯å€§ãããªãããããšããã€ã¡ãŒãžã§ããA/Bãã¹ãã宿œããå Žåã®ããã«ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã®ã°ã«ãŒããåŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã«åã ã«ã©ã³ãã ã«åããå Žåã¯ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã¯$e=0.5$ãšãªããŸããããããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®çã®å€ã¯åºæ¬çã«äºåã«ã¯ããããªããããå®åäžã¯åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®å€ãæšå®ããå¿ èŠããããŸããå ·äœçã«ã¯ã$Z$ãç®ç倿°ã$X$ã説æå€æ°ãšããã¢ãã«ãäœæãããã®ã¢ãã«ãç®åºãã確ç$Prâ¡(Z=1|X)$ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®æšå®å€ãšããŠçšããŸãã
3-2. åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«æ±ããããæ§è³ª
åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããåæã§ã¯ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«é¢ããŠä»¥äžã®æ§è³ªãæãç«ã€ããšãä»®å®ããŠããç¹ã«æ³šæãå¿ èŠã§ããå®éã«ãããã®æ§è³ªãæãç«ã€ããã«ã¯ãã匷ãç¡èŠã§ããå²ãåœãŠæ¡ä»¶ããªã©ã®ããã€ãã®æ¡ä»¶ãå¿ èŠã§ãã詳现ã¯åèæç®ã®ïŒãïŒãªã©ããåç §ãã ããã
- æ§è³ªïŒïŒåŠçœ®å²ãåœãŠãšå ±å€éã®æ¡ä»¶ä»ãç¬ç«æ§ïŒ
Z \perp X|e
ãã®æ§è³ªã¯ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e$ã®å€ãçãããµã³ãã«ã ããéãããšããåŠçœ®çŸ€($Z=1$)ã§ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€($Z=0$)ã§ãå ±å€é$X$ã®ååžã¯åããšããããšã衚ããŠããŸããã€ãŸãã
P(X|e, Z=1) = P(X|e, Z=0)
ãšããããšã衚ããŠããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒã
ãã®æ§è³ªãããåŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã§å
±å€éã®ååžãç°ãªã£ãŠãããšããŠãã䞡矀ã®åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãæããããšã§å
±å€éã®ååžãçããããããšãå¯èœã«ãªããŸãã

âââââââââââââå³ïŒïŒ åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®æ§è³ªïŒã®ã€ã¡ãŒãž
- æ§è³ªïŒïŒåŠçœ®å²ãåœãŠãšçµæå€æ°ã®æ¡ä»¶ä»ãç¬ç«æ§ïŒ
Z \perp Y^{(0)}, Y^{(1)}|e
ãã®æ§è³ªã¯åŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e$ã®å€ãçãããµã³ãã«ã ããéãããšãåŠçœ®çŸ€($Z=1$)ã§ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€($Z=0$)ã§ãçµæå€æ°$Y^{(1)}$ãš$Y^{(0)}$ã®ååžã¯åããšããããšã衚ããŠããŸããã€ãŸãã
P(Y^{(1)}|e, Z=1) = P(Y^{(1)}|e, Z=0)\\
P(Y^{(0)}|e, Z=1) = P(Y^{(0)}|e, Z=0)
ãšããããšã衚ããŠããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒã

ââââââââââââââå³ïŒïŒ åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®æ§è³ªïŒã®ã€ã¡ãŒãž
3-3. é確çéã¿ä»ãæ³ïŒIPWæ³)
åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããŠATEïŒ$\tau_{ATE}=E[Y^{(1)}]-E[Y^{(0)}]$ïŒãæšå®ããæ¹æ³ã®äžã€ããé確çéã¿ä»ãïŒInverse Probability Weighting, IPWïŒæ³ã§ããIPWæ³ã§ã¯ã以äžã®åŒã®éãATEãæšå®ããŸãã
\hat{\tau}_{ATE}^{IPW} = \frac{1}{N'_1} \sum_{i=1}^{N}w_{i}^{(1)}Y_i - \frac{1}{N'_0} \sum_{i=1}^{N}w_{i}^{(0)}Y_i
\tag{3}
ããã§ã$w_i^{(1)}=\frac{Z_i}{e_i}$ã$w_i^{(0)}=\frac{1-Z_i}{1-e_i}$ã$N_1^{'}=\sum_{i=1}^N w_i^{(1)}$ã$N_0^{'}=\sum_{i=1}^N w_i^{(0)}$ã§ãã第äžé ã¯$E[Y^{(1)}]$ã®äžåæšå®éã«ãªã£ãŠããã第äºé ã¯$E[Y^{(0)}]$ã®äžåæšå®éã«ãªã£ãŠããããšããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®æ§è³ªïŒãçšããŠç€ºãããšãã§ããŸããïŒãã詳ãã説æã¯åèæç®ïŒãåç §ããŠãã ãããïŒ
å ·äœçãªèšç®æé ãèŠãŠãããŸãã第äžé ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€($Z=1$)ã®ãµã³ãã«ã«å¯ŸããŠãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®éæ°ïŒ$1/e_i$ïŒã§éã¿ä»ããã$Y_i$ã®æåŸ å€ãèšç®ããŠããŸããã€ãŸããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã$e_i$ã®ãµã³ãã«ã¯$1/e_i$人åãšããŠ$Y_i$ãè¶³ãåãããéã¿ä»ãã«ããå¢å ããéèšäžã®ãµã³ãã«æ°$N'_1$ã§å²ã£ãŠããŸããããã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã倧ããªãµã³ãã«ã®éã¿ãå°ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãå°ããªãµã³ãã«ã®éã¿ã倧ããããããã§ãçµæå€æ°$Y_i$ã®å¹³åãèšç®ããŠããŸãã第äºé ãåæ§ã«ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ïŒ$Z=0$ïŒã®ãµã³ãã«ã«å¯ŸããŠã$1/(1-e_i)$ã§éã¿ä»ããã$Y_i$ã®æåŸ å€ãèšç®ããŠããŸãã
衚ïŒã®ããŒã¿ã«åŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e_i$ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å¯Ÿããéã¿$w_i^{(1)}$ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã®éã¿ä»ãããçµæå€æ°$w_i^{(1)} Y_i$ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã«å¯Ÿããéã¿$w_i^{(0)}$ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã®éã¿ä»ãããçµæå€æ°$w_i^{(0)} Y_i$ã远å ãããã®ã衚ïŒã«ç€ºããŸãããèµ€ç·éšåã®èšç®ããåŒ(3)ã®ç¬¬äžé ããéç·éšåã®èšç®ããåŒ(3)ã®ç¬¬äºé ãæ±ããããšãã§ããŸãã
ââââââââââââ衚ïŒïŒ 衚ïŒã«IPWæ³ã§çšããéã远å ãã衚

3-4. IPWæ³ã®ã€ã¡ãŒãž
ãããŸã§IPWæ³ã®èšç®åŒã説æããŸããããããã§ã¯IPWæ³ããã£ãšåã¿ç ããã€ã¡ãŒãžã説æããŸãã
TVCMæœçã®å¹ææ€èšŒã®äŸã§ã¯ã幎霢局ãé«ããTVèŠèŽæéãé·ããŠãŒã¶ãŒã¯ãåŠçœ®ãåããïŒTVCMãèŠãïŒå¯èœæ§ãé«ããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã倧ãããªããããç¶æ³ãèããŸããããã®ããã«ããŠãŒã¶ãŒãåŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã®ããããã«æç€ºçã«å²ãåœãŠãããªãç¶æ³ã§ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã§åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã¯ç°ãªãå Žåãå€ãã§ããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãåã$e$ã®å€ããšããµã³ãã«ãéããŠãããšããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®å®çŸ©ããããã®ãã¡ã®$e$ã®å²åã®ãµã³ãã«ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãæ®ãã®$1-e$ã®å²åã®ãµã³ãã«ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠãããŠããããšã«ãªããŸããäŸãã°ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã0.1çšåºŠã®ãµã³ãã«ã1,000人ãããšããçŽ100人ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãæ®ãã®çŽ900人ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠãããããšã«ãªããŸããã€ãŸããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã倧ããªãµã³ãã«ã¯åŠçœ®çŸ€ã«åããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãå°ãããµã³ãã«ã¯å¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã«åãããšã«ãªããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒã

ââââââââââå³ïŒïŒ ãµã³ãã«å
šäœã»åŠçœ®çŸ€ã»å¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååž
IPWæ³ã§ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã»å¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã®åããè£æ£ããŠããŸãã
ãŸããåŒ(3)第äžé
ã§$E[Y^{(1)}]$ãæšå®ããéã«ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=1$ïŒã®ãµã³ãã«ã®$Y_i$ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®éæ°$1/e_i$ã§éã¿ä»ãããããšã§ããµã³ãã«å
šäœã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã«ããšã¥ã$Y^{(1)}$ã®æåŸ
å€ãæšå®ããŠããŸããåæ§ã«ã第äºé
ã§$E[Y^{(0)}]$ãæšå®ããéã«ã察ç
§çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=0$ïŒã®ãµã³ãã«ã®$Y_i$ã$1/(1-e_i)$ ã§éã¿ä»ãããããšã§ããµã³ãã«å
šäœã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã«ããšã¥ã$Y^{(0)}$ã®æåŸ
å€ãæšå®ããŠããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒã

âââââââââââââå³ïŒïŒ IPWæ³ã«ããATEæšå®ã®ã€ã¡ãŒãž
ãããŠãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®æ§è³ªïŒãèžãŸãããšãIPWæ³ã¯åŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžãæããããšã§ãè£æ£åŸã®åŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã®å
±å€éã®ååžãæããŠããããšã«ãªããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒãããã«ãããåŠçœ®çŸ€ã®ãŠãŒã¶ãŒãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã®ãŠãŒã¶ãŒã®å±æ§ã»è¡åã®éãã«èµ·å ããã»ã¬ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã€ã¢ã¹ã®åœ±é¿ã軜æžãããã粟緻ã«ATEãæšå®ããããšãã§ããŸãã

ââå³ïŒïŒ åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«ããè£æ£åŸã®åŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã®å
±å€éã®ååžïŒATEãæšå®ããå ŽåïŒ
4. åŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å¯ŸããåŠçœ®å¹æïŒATTïŒã®æšå®
ãããŸã§ã¯ããµã³ãã«å
šäœã«å¯Ÿããå¹³åçãªåŠçœ®å¹æã§ããATEãèããŠããŸãããäžæ¹ã§ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å¯Ÿããå¹³ååŠçœ®å¹æïŒAverage Treatment Effect on the Treated, ATTïŒãèããããšãæå¹ãªå ŽåããããŸãã
äŸãã°ãTVCMæœçã宿œãããšãã«ã©ãã»ã©å¹æããã£ãã®ãããã®è²»çšå¯Ÿå¹æãæ€èšŒããéã«ã¯ãå®éã«TVCMãèŠããŠãŒã¶ãŒïŒåŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒã«éå®ããåŠçœ®å¹æã枬å®ããã»ããé©åã§ããããæ¬ç¯ã§ã¯ãATTã®å®çŸ©ããã³IPWæ³ãçšããŠATTãæšå®ããæ¹æ³ã«ã€ããŠèª¬æããŸãã
4-1. ATTã®å®çŸ©
ATTã¯ã以äžã®åŒã®éããçµæå€æ°$Y_i^{(1)}$ãš$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®åŠçœ®çŸ€ã«éå®ããïŒ$Z=1$ã®æ¡ä»¶ä»ãïŒæåŸ å€ã®å·®åãšããŠå®çŸ©ãããŸãã
\tau_{ATT} = E[Y^{(1)}|Z=1] - E[Y^{(0)}|Z=1]
çæ³çã«ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=1$ïŒã«ãããçµæå€æ°$Y^{(1)}$, $Y^{(0)}$ãçšããŠATTãæšå®ããããšãã§ããŸãã
\hat{\tau}_{ATT} = \frac{1}{N_1} \sum_{i=1}^{N} Z_iY_i^{(1)} - \frac{1}{N_1} \sum_{i=1}^{N} Z_iY_i^{(0)}
\tag{4}
åŒ(4)ã®èšç®ã®ã€ã¡ãŒãžã瀺ãããã«ã衚ïŒã®ããŒã¿äŸãäžéšæç²ãããã®ã衚ïŒã«ç€ºããŸããåŒ(4)第äžé ããã³ç¬¬äºé ã¯ãããããèµ€è²ã®å®ç·ããã³éè²ã®å®ç·ã§å²ã£ãéšåã®å¹³åå€ã«çžåœããŸããåŒ(4)第äžé ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãããçµæå€æ°$Y^{(1)}$ïŒåŠçœ®ãåããå Žåã®çµæå€æ°ïŒã®å¹³åå€ã§ããããã芳枬ãããããŒã¿ããèšç®ããããšãã§ããŸããããããåŒ(4)第äºé ã¯åŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãããçµæå€æ°$Y^{(0)}$ïŒåŠçœ®ãåããªãã£ãå Žåã®çµæå€æ°ïŒã®å¹³åå€ã§ããã芳枬ãããããŒã¿ããã¯èšç®ã§ããŸãããããã§ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããŠãããæšå®ããããšãèããŸãã
âââââââââââââââââ衚ïŒïŒ 衚ïŒã®ããŒã¿äŸã®æç²

4-2. IPWæ³ã«ããATTã®æšå®æ¹æ³
åŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å¯Ÿããå¹³ååŠçœ®å¹æïŒATTïŒããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«ããéã¿ä»ãïŒIPWïŒã掻çšããããšã§æšå®ããããšãã§ããŸãã
\hat{\tau}_{ATT}^{IPW} = \frac{1}{N_i} \sum_{i=1}^{N} Z_iY_i - \frac{1}{N_0^{ATT}} \sum_{i=1}^{N} w_i^{\prime(0)}Y_i
\tag{5}
ããã§ã$w_i^{\prime(0)}=\frac{(1-Z_i)e_{i}}{1-e_i}$ã$N_0^{ATT}=\sum_{i=1}^{N}w_i^{\prime(0)}$ã§ããåŒ(5)第äžé ã¯ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=1$ïŒãã芳枬ãããçµæå€æ°$Y_i$ã®å¹³åå€ã§ããåŒ(5)第äºé ã¯ãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã®ãµã³ãã«ïŒ$Z=0$ïŒã«å¯ŸããŠã$e_i/(1-e_i)$ã§éã¿ä»ããã$Y_i^{(0)}$ã®å¹³åå€ãèšç®ããŠããŸããèšãæãããšãå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã®ãµã³ãã«ã$e_i/(1-e_i)$人åãšããŠã$Y_i^{(0)}$ãè¶³ãåãããéã¿ä»ãã«ããå€åããéèšäžã®ãµã³ãã«æ°ã«çžåœãã$N_0^{ATT}$ã§å²ã£ãŠããŸãïŒè¡šïŒã®éè²ã®ç¹ç·ã§å²ã£ãéšåã®èšç®ïŒã$e_i/(1-e_i)$ã¯$e_i$ã«æ¯äŸããŠå€§ãããªããããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã倧ããªãµã³ãã«ã®éã¿ã¯å€§ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãå°ããªãµã³ãã«ã®éã¿ã¯å°ãããªããŸããã€ãŸããå¯Ÿç §çŸ€ã®ãµã³ãã«ã®äžã§ããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãã€ãŸãåŠçœ®çŸ€ãžã®å²ãåœãŠç¢ºçããã倧ããªãµã³ãã«ãéèŠããŠçµæå€æ°ãéèšããŠããŸãã
4-3. IPWæ³ã«ããATTã®æšå®ã€ã¡ãŒãž
ATTãæšå®ããå ŽåãåŒ(5)ã¯ã察ç
§çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã®åããè£æ£ããŠããŸããããªãã¡ã察ç
§çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžããåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã«æããŠããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒã察ç
§çŸ€ã¯åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãã€ãŸãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠããã確çãäœããµã³ãã«ãå€ãããã$1/(1-e_i)$åããŠãµã³ãã«å
šäœã®åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã«åãããããã«$e_i$åããããšã§åŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã«åããã«ããã€ã¡ãŒãžã§ãã

ââââââââââââå³ïŒïŒ 察ç
§çŸ€ã®åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ååžã®è£æ£ã€ã¡ãŒãž
ATTãæšå®ããéã¯ã$E[Y^{(0)}|Z=1]$ãæšå®ããããã«ãåŒ(5)第äºé
ã®ããã«å¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ïŒ$Z_i=0$ïŒã®ãµã³ãã«ã®$Y_i^{(0)}$ã$e_i/(1-e_i)$ã§éã¿ä»ãããããšã§ãåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžã«ããšã¥ã$Y^{(0)}$ã®æåŸ
å€ãæšå®ããŠããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒã

âââââââââââââå³ïŒïŒ IPWæ³ã«ããATTæšå®ã®ã€ã¡ãŒãž
ãŸããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®æ§è³ª1ãèžãŸãããšãåŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã«ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã®ååžãæããããšã§ãè£æ£åŸã®åŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã®å
±å€éã®ååžãæããŠããŸããç¹ã«ãã®å Žåã¯ã察ç
§çŸ€ã«ãããå
±å€éã®ååžããåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«ãããå
±å€éã®ååžã«æããŠããŸãïŒå³ïŒïŒãããã«ãããåŠçœ®çŸ€ã®ãŠãŒã¶ãŒããåŠçœ®ãåããããšã«ãã£ãŠã©ãã ãçµæå€æ°ãå€åããããããç²Ÿç·»ã«æããããšãã§ããŸãã

ââå³ïŒïŒ åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«ããè£æ£åŸã®åŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ã®å
±å€éã®ååžïŒATTãæšå®ããå ŽåïŒ
5. è£è¶³ïŒã»ã¬ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã€ã¢ã¹ã®å¯èŠå
ãã®ç¯ã§ã¯ãå¹³ååŠçœ®å¹æïŒATEïŒãåçŽãªéèšã«ãã£ãŠæšå®ããå€$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ãšçã®å€$\tau_{ATE}$ãšã®å·®ïŒã»ã¬ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã€ã¢ã¹ïŒã«ã€ããŠãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãçšããŠå¯èŠåããæ¹æ³ã説æããŸããç¹ã«ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãšçµæå€æ°ã«æ£ãšè² ã©ã¡ãã®çžé¢ããããã«ãã£ãŠãã€ã¢ã¹ã®æ¹åïŒåçŽãªå·®åã®éèšãé倧æšå®ãšãªããããããã¯éå°æšå®ãšãªããïŒãå€ããããšãèŠãŸãã
ãŸããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e$ãšçµæå€æ°$Y^{(1)}$, $Y^{(0)}$ã«è² ã®çžé¢ããããã€ãŸããåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠããããããµã³ãã«ã®ã»ããçµæå€æ°ãå°ããåŸåãããå Žåã«ã€ããŠèããŸããTVCMæœçã®å¹ææ€èšŒã®äŸã®ããã«ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãé«ããµã³ãã«ïŒTVCMãèŠãå¯èœæ§ãé«ããŠãŒã¶ãŒïŒã»ã©çµæå€æ°ãå°ããïŒã¢ããªå©çšæéãçãïŒãããªç¶æ³ããã®å Žåã«çžåœããŸããç°¡åã®ãããåŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e$ã«å¯ŸããŠçµæå€æ°ã®æåŸ
å€$E[Y^{(1)}|e]$, $E[Y^{(0)}|e]$ãç·åœ¢ã«æžå°ããç¶æ³ãèããŸãïŒå³10(a)ïŒã
ãã®ç¶æ³ã§ãATEã®åçŽãªéèšã«ããæšå®å€$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ãå¯èŠåããŠã¿ãŸãã2-2.ã§èª¬æããããã«ã$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ã¯$E[Y_i^{(1)}|Z=1]-E[Y_i^{(0)}|Z=0]$ã®æšå®éã§ããåŠçœ®çŸ€ïŒ$Z=1$ïŒã¯åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãæ¯èŒç倧ããéå£ã§ããããšãèžãŸãããšã第äžé
ã®$E[Y^{(1)}|Z=1]$ã¯ãå³10(a)ã®$E[Y^{(1)}|e]$ã®ã°ã©ãã®å³åŽã®å€ãåããŸããäžæ¹ã§ã察ç
§çŸ€ïŒ$Z=0$ïŒã¯åŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãæ¯èŒçå°ããéå£ãšãªãããã第äºé
ã®$E[Y^{(0)}|Z=0]$ã¯ãå³10(a)ã®$E[Y^{(0)}|e]$ã®ã°ã©ãã®å·ŠåŽã®å€ãåããŸãããããã£ãŠã$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ã¯å³10(a)å³åŽã®çãç¢å°ã§ç€ºãããšãã§ããŸãã
次ã«ãATEã®çã®å€$\tau_{ATE}$ã®å¯èŠåãè¡ããŸãã$\tau_{ATE}$ã¯$E[Y^{(1)}]-E[Y^{(0)}]$ãšå®çŸ©ãããŸããåŠçœ®çŸ€ãšå¯Ÿç
§çŸ€ãåããããµã³ãã«å
šäœã¯ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ãäžéçšåºŠã®éå£ãšãªãã®ã§ã$E[Y^{(1)}]$ãš$E[Y^{(0)}]$ã¯ããããå³10(a)ã®$E[Y^{(1)}|e]$ãš$E[Y^{(0)}|e]$ã®ã°ã©ãã®ã»ãŒäžå€®ã®å€ãåããŸãããããã£ãŠã$\tau_{ATE}$ã¯å³10(a)äžå€®ã®ç¢å°ã§è¡šãããšãã§ããŸããäºã€ã®ç¢å°ã®é·ããããªãã¡$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ãš$\tau_{ATE}$ã®å€§ããããšæ¯ã¹ããšãåè
ã®ã»ããç¢å°ã¯çããå°ããå€ãåãããšã«ãªããŸããã€ãŸããåçŽãªéèšã«ããæšå®ã¯éå°æšå®ã«ãªããŸãã
次ã«ãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢$e$ãšçµæå€æ°$Y^{(1)}$, $Y^{(0)}$ã«æ£ã®çžé¢ããããã€ãŸããåŠçœ®çŸ€ã«å²ãåœãŠããããããµã³ãã«ã®ã»ããçµæå€æ°ã倧ããåŸåãããå ŽåãèããŸãïŒå³10(b)ïŒãå³10(a)ã®å Žåãšåæ§ã«$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ãš$\tau_{ATE}$ãå¯èŠåãããšã$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ã¯å³10(b)å³åŽã®é·ãç¢å°ã§ç€ºãããšãã§ãã$\tau_{ATE}$ã¯å³10(b)äžå€®ã®ç¢å°ã§è¡šãããšãã§ããŸããäºã€ã®ç¢å°ã®é·ããæ¯ã¹ããšã$\tau Ì_{ATE}^{naive}$ã¯$\tau_{ATE}$ãã倧ããå€ãåããåçŽãªéèšã«ããæšå®ã¯é倧æšå®ã«ãªãããšãèŠãŠåããŸãã
以äžã®ããã«å¯èŠåãè¡ãããšã§ãåçŽãªéèšã«ãã£ãŠå¹ææ€èšŒãè¡ã£ãå Žåã®ã»ã¬ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã€ã¢ã¹ã®æ¹åããããããããªããŸãã
å®éã®ããŒã¿åæã«ãããŠããå³10ã®çžŠè»žãšæšªè»žã®å€ãæšå®å€ã«çœ®ãæããŠå¯èŠåããããšã广æ€èšŒã®åææ¹éã«ã€ããŠäœããã³ããåŸããããããããŸããã

ââââââââââââââå³10ïŒ ã»ã¬ã¯ã·ã§ã³ãã€ã¢ã¹ã®å¯èŠå
6. ãŸãšã
ä»åã¯ã广æ€èšŒã®ææ³ãšããŠãåŸåã¹ã³ã¢ã«ããåææ³ã玹ä»ããŸãããæ¬èšäºãæœçã®å¹ææ€èšŒã®å®åã«æºããæ¹ã ã®ãåèã«ãªãã°å¹žãã§ãã
åèæç®
- 岩波ããŒã¿ãµã€ãšã³ã¹åè¡å§å¡äŒç·š, å è€è« ä», 岩波ããŒã¿ãµã€ãšã³ã¹ Vol.3 âå æå¹ææšå®ã®å¿çšâ, 岩波æžåº.
- å®äºç¿å€ª, 广æ€èšŒå ¥éïœæ£ããæ¯èŒã®ããã®å ææšè«ïŒèšéçµæžåŠã®åºç€, æè¡è©è«ç€Ÿ.
- æéåŽå®, 調æ»èгå¯ããŒã¿ã®çµ±èšç§åŠâå ææšè«ã»éžæãã€ã¢ã¹ã»ããŒã¿èå, 岩波æžåº.
- 岩åŽåŠ, çµ±èšçå ææšè«, æåæžåº.