ã¯ããã«
ããã®ã¢ããªäœãããšæã£ããããã£ããå·¥æ°ã©ã®ãããïŒã
ããèãããŠãã€ãããã£ãã ã人æãããã§ãããããšçããŠããŸã£ãçµéšã¯ãªãã§ããããã
以åãã"å·¥æ°ãè¶³ããªã" ããã®è±åŽã ãšããèšäºã§ãèšç»ã«å¯ŸããŠå·¥æ°ãè¶³ããªãå±é¢ã®è©±ãæžããŸãããä»åã¯ãã®å段ãèŠç©ãããã©ãåºãããã©ãäŒãããã®è©±ã§ãã
ããã£ãããã®ãããããšããæ°åã ãã§çããã®ã¯ãããããŸããã
æŠç®èŠç©ããã¯æ¬¡ã®3ã€ãæŒãããŠåºãå¿
èŠããããšèããŠããŸãã
- ã¹ããŒã¯ãã«ããŒãšææçéã§ããæ°é à åäœãããã®å·¥æ°ãšããåŒã§åºã
- åäœãããã®å·¥æ°ã¯äºæ³ã§ã¯ãªããéå»ã®å®çžŸã䜿ã£ãŠæ±ãã
- èŠç©ããã¯äºæ³ãªã®ã§ã1ã€ã®æ°åã§ã¯ãªãå¹ ãšç¢ºçã®ååžã§äŒãã
ããã£ãããã®ãããããçãããéã
ãŸããããã£ããã©ã®ãããïŒããšèãåŽã®äºæ
ããããŸãã
äºæ¥è²¬ä»»è
ãçµå¶è
ã¯ããããããªãããæ©ã倿ãããããã§ãã詳现ãªèŠç©ãããäœé±éãåŸ
ã£ãŠããããªããèããããªãæ°æã¡ã¯ããããããŸãããã
åé¡ã¯ããã«æ ¹æ ã®ãªãæ°åã ãã§çããŠããŸãããšã§ãã
äžåºŠå£ã«ããæ°åã¯ç¬ãæ©ãããŸãã
åŸããæ£åŒãªèŠç©ãããåºããšããåã¯ã人æã£ãŠèšã£ãŠãããããšæ¯ã¹ãããã
ããªãã§ãããªã«ãããã®ïŒããšèãããŠããæ ¹æ ããªãã®ã§æèŠã©ããã®èšãåãã«ãªããããããç©ºäžæŠã§ãã
èããåŽãçããåŽãæªããªãã®ã«ãããéã£ãŠããŸãã
æ©ã倿ããããšããçžæã®èŠæã«ãæ ¹æ ã€ãã§çŽ æ©ãå¿ããããã®éå
·ãããããã話ããåŒããšãååžãã ãšèããŠããŸãã
æ°é à åäœãããã®å·¥æ°
æŠç®èŠç©ããã¯ãæ°é à åäœãããã®èŠæš¡ããšããåŒã§åºããŸãã
ã¹ããŒã¯ãã«ããŒãšææçéã§ããåäœ
äœããæ°éãã«ãããã倧äºã§ãã
ç§ãæ¬åœã«äŒãããã®ã¯ãã¹ããŒã¯ãã«ããŒãšææçéãã§ããåäœã§èŠç©ãããšããããšã§ãã
èŠç©ããã¯çžæãšåæããããã®éå
·ã§ãã
ãã¡ããããã粟緻ãªåäœã§èŠç©ãã£ãŠããçžæããã®åäœãçè§£ã§ããªããã°ãçµå±ããªãã§ãããªã«ããããã ãã®ç©ºäžæŠã«æ»ã£ãŠããŸããŸãã
ããšãã°ã宿ããããžã§ããAPIã¯ç»é¢ãšã¯å䟡æããŸã£ããéããŸãã
çžæããã®éããçè§£ããŠããããªããæŠç®ã®æç¹ãããç»é¢â¯åããããâ¯æ¬ãAPIâ¯æ¬ããšå¥ã
ã«æ±ãããšããã§ãããã
ã§ããå®éã«ã¯ããã§ãªãããšã®ã»ããå€ãã§ãããã
ãã®ç¹ãç»é¢ã¯ç®ã«èŠããŠã誰ã§ãæ°ããããŸãã
äžè¬çã«åæã§ããåäœã¯ç®ã«èŠããŠçè§£ããããç»é¢æ°ã«ãªãããšãå€ããšèããŠããŸãã
ã§ã¯ãç»é¢æ°ã ãã§èŠç©ãã£ãããããããAPIã®å·¥æ°ã¯ã©ããžè¡ã£ãŠããŸãã®ã§ããããã
å®å¿ããŠãã ãããåŸã§åºãŠãããé廿¡ä»¶ã®ç·å·¥æ°ãã«ã¯ããããAPIã®å·¥æ°ãå«ããŠèšé²ããŸãããªã®ã§ãå¥ã«æ°ããªããŠãã1ç»é¢ãããã®å¹³åã®äžã«åžåãããŠããŸãã
ç»é¢æ°ã§åŒãç«ãŠã
å·¥æ° = ç»é¢æ° à 1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ°
ä»®ã«20ç»é¢ à 0.5人æ = 10人æããšãã£ãå
·åã§ãã
â»ãã®èšäºã®æ°åã¯ãã¹ãŠèª¬æçšã®äŸã§ãã
åŒããããšãè°è«ããé«ãã»å®ããã§ã¯ãªããããã®ç»é¢ã¯æ¬åœã«å¿
èŠãããšããã¹ã³ãŒãã®è©±ã«å€ãããŸãã
ç»é¢æ°ãå€ãã£ãŠããåŒã«å
¥ãçŽãã ãã§åŒãçŽããŸãã
1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ°ã¯å®çžŸããåºã
1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ°ãããã®ç»é¢ã¯0.5人æãããããªããšäºæ³ã§æ±ºããªãããšã倧äºã§ãã
åŒã®åœ¢ãããŠããŠããäžèº«ãåãªãããã£ãããã®ãããããšå€§å·®ãããŸããã
1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ°ã¯é廿¡ä»¶ã®å®çžŸã®å¹³åã䜿ããŸãã
1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ° = é廿¡ä»¶ã®ç·å·¥æ° ÷ é廿¡ä»¶ã®ç»é¢æ°
ããã¯æžå»ºãŠã®åªå䟡ãšåãã ãšèããŠããŸãã
ããŠã¹ã¡ãŒã«ãŒã«æåã®çžè«ããããšããåªå䟡â¯äžåãªã®ã§ã35åªãªãâ¯â¯äžåãããããšçããŠããããŸãããã®åªå䟡ã¯éå»ã«å»ºãŠãå®¶ã®å¹³åã§ãããããã³ãå€å£ã®ã°ã¬ãŒãã§éé¡ã¯å€ãããŸãããããã¯ä»æ§ã现ããæ±ºãŸã£ãŠããæ±ºãŸã話ã§ããæŠç®ã®æç¹ã§ããã®å®¶ã ãã®ä»æ§ãå èªã¿ããŠå䟡ããããããã§ã¯ãããŸããã
ã¢ããªãåãã§ãã
æŠç®ã®æ®µéã§ã¯å®çžŸã®å¹³åã䜿ãã詳现ãªä»æ§åãã§ããŠãããç»é¢ããšã«ç©ã¿äžããã仿§ã§ãããããªåæã¯è©³çްãªä»æ§ãã§ããå
ã§æ±ºãŸããã®ã§ãã
ããã«èšããšãå®¶ã®èŠç©ããã§ã¯ãæ¬äœå·¥äºã¯åªå䟡ã倿§ã諞費çšã¯å¥ããšåããŠåºãŠããŸãããã
æœäž»ãã倿§ã¯å¥ã«ããããã®ããšçè§£ããŠãããããåããŠè©±ããããã§ãã
ã¢ããªã®ããããAPIãåãã§ãçžæãçè§£ããŠããããªãåããŠåºããããã§ãªããã°æ¬äœïŒç»é¢ïŒã®å䟡ã«å«ããŠåºãããããã䜿ãåãã ãšèããŠããŸãã
ã¡ãªã¿ã«ããã®ã䌌ãé廿¡ä»¶ã®å®çžŸããäºæž¬ãããèãæ¹ã¯ãFlyvbjerg ããæå±ããåç §ã¯ã©ã¹äºæž¬ïŒReference Class ForecastingïŒãšã»ãŒåããã®ã§ãã
å®çžŸã¯ãã®åã§èšé²ããŠãã
å®çžŸããŸã å°ãªãããŒã ã¯ä»æ¥ããèšé²ãå§ããŸããããæäœéããã ãããã°äœ¿ããŸãã
| æ¡ä»¶å | ç»é¢æ° | ç·å·¥æ°ïŒäººæïŒ | æé | ã¡ã¢ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| æ¡ä»¶AïŒäŸïŒ | 20 | 9 | 4ã¶æ | 管çç»é¢äžå¿ãããã2æ¬ãå€éšAPI飿º1〠|
| æ¡ä»¶BïŒäŸïŒ | 16 | 10 | 5ã¶æ | 決æžé£æºãã |
ãã€ã³ãã¯2ã€ã§ãã
- ç»é¢ã®æ°ãæ¹ãããŒã ã§åºå®ãããäŸãã°ãURLãå€ãããã®ã1ç»é¢ãã¢ãŒãã«ãã¿ãã¯æ°ããªãããªã©ãã«ãŒã«ããã¬ããšå¹³åããã¬ãŸã
- ç·å·¥æ°ã«ã¯èšèšã»ãã¹ãã»PMã»ãããã»APIãå«ããæ¡ä»¶å šäœã®å·¥æ°ãå šéšå ¥ããŸããã ãããããç»é¢æ°ã ãã§èŠç©ãã£ãŠãæŒããŸãã
èŠç©ãããååžã§çãã
ãã1ã€ãèŠç©ããã«ã€ããŠæŒãããŠããããããšããããŸãã
èŠç©ããã¯äºæ³ã§ãã
äºæ³ã«ã¯å¿
ããã¬ããããŸãã
倩æ°äºå ±ããææ¥ã¯éšã§ããã§ã¯ãªããéæ°Žç¢ºç70%ããšçããããã«ãäºæ³ã¯æ¬æ¥ã確çååžã§çããã¹ããã®ã ãšæããŸãã
ç¹ã«æŠç®ãã§ãŒãºã¯ä»æ§ã決ãŸã£ãŠããªãäžç¢ºå®äºé ã ããã§ããããã§ã10人æã§ãããš1ã€ã®æ°åã§çããã®ã¯ãããããªãããšãããã£ããµããããŠããã®ãšåãã§ããå¹ ãšç¢ºçã§çããã»ããèª å®ãªå¯Ÿå¿ã«ãªããŸãã
ãã®å¹ ã¯ä»æ§ã決ãŸãã«ã€ããŠçãŸã£ãŠãããŸããMcConnell ãåºããäžç¢ºå®æ§ã®ã³ãŒã³ïŒCone of UncertaintyïŒãšããŠç¥ãããŠããèãæ¹ã§ãã
äžç¹èŠç©æ³ãå®çžŸããåºã
ååžãæè»œã«è¡šãæ¹æ³ãäžç¹èŠç©æ³ã§ãã1ã€ã®æ°åã§ã¯ãªã3ã€ã®æ°åãåºããŸãã
- 楜芳å€(a): ããŸããã£ãå Žå
- æå¯èœå€(m): ãã¡ã°ããããããªå Žå
- æ²èгå€(b): ããŸããããªãã£ãå Žå
ãã®3ã€ãåã§æ±ºããã«å®çžŸããåºããŸãã
äŸãã°ãä»ã®è©±ã§ç»é¢æ°ã¯20ã24ïŒç»é¢ã¯æžãããå¢ããã¡ã§ãïŒãéå»å®çžŸã®1ç»é¢ãããå·¥æ°ãæå°0.4ã»å¹³å0.5ã»æå€§0.75人æã ã£ããšããŸãã
æ¥œèŠ³å€ a = 20ç»é¢ à 0.4人æ = 8人æ
æå¯èœ m = 20ç»é¢ à 0.5人æ = 10人æ
æ²èŠ³å€ b = 24ç»é¢ à 0.75人æ = 18人æ
ãªããäžç¹èŠç©æ³ã¯å®çžŸãå°ãªããšãã®è¿äŒŒã ãšç§ã¯èããŠããŸããäŒŒãæ¡ä»¶ã®å®çžŸãååã«æºãŸã£ãŠãããªãã3ç¹ã«äžžãããå®çžŸã®ã°ãã€ãïŒååžïŒãã®ãã®ã䜿ãã»ããçŽ çŽã§ãã
éé¡ãšæéãšç¢ºçã§äŒãã
äžç¹ãåºãããæåŸ å€ãšå¹ ãåºããŸããäŸã®æ°åã§ã¯ãããªããŸãïŒäººæå䟡100äžåã3人ããŒã ãšããå Žåã®äŸïŒã
| å·¥æ° | éé¡ | æéïŒ3人ã§åçŽèšç®ïŒ | |
|---|---|---|---|
| å¹ | 8ã18人æ | 800ã1,800äžå | çŽ2.7ã6ã¶æ |
| æåŸ å€ïŒäºåäºåã®ç·ïŒ | 11人æ | 1,100äžå | çŽ3.7ã¶æ |
| çŽ8å²ã®ç¢ºçã§åãŸãç· | çŽ12.7人æ | çŽ1,270äžå | çŽ4.2ã¶æ |
æå¯èœå€ã¯10人æã§ããæåŸ å€ã¯11人æã«ãªããŸãããœãããŠã§ã¢éçºã¯æ©ãçµããæ¹åã«ã¯éçãããã®ã«ãé ããæ¹åã«ã¯ãããã§ãå»¶ã³ãŸããæ²èŠ³åŽã«è£Ÿãé·ãã¶ããå¹³åã¯å³ã«ãããããã§ãã
èšç®ã®äžèº«ïŒPERTæ³ãšããŒã¿ååžïŒ
äžç¹èŠç©ããã§ã¯å·¥æ°ãããŒã¿ååžã«åŸããšèããŠã次ã®åŒã§æåŸ å€ãšæšæºåå·®ãæ±ããŸãïŒPERTæ³ïŒãããŒã¿ååžã¯å³ã«é·ã裟ãåŒã圢ã衚ããã®ã§ãèŠç©ããã«åããŠããŸãã
æåŸ
å€ = (a + 4m + b) / 6 = (8 + 4 à 10 + 18) / 6 = 11人æ
æšæºåå·® = (b - a) / 6 = (18 - 8) / 6 â 1.7人æ
çŽ8å²ã®ç· â æåŸ
å€ + æšæºåå·® = 11 + 1.67 â 12.7人æ
ãæåŸ å€ + æšæºåå·® â çŽ8å²ãã¯ãæ£èŠååžã«è¿ããšã¿ãªãããšãã®ç®å®ïŒå³å¯ã«ã¯çŽ84%ïŒã§ãã
äœãæžããããã€ãã
- PERTã®åŒèªäœãããŒã¿ååžã®è¿äŒŒã§ãã粟å¯ããããå¹ ã§è©±ãããã®éå ·ãšå²ãåã£ãŠããŸã
- èŠæš¡ã倧ãããªãã»ã©1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ°ã¯å¢ããã¡ã§ãïŒèŠæš¡ã®äžçµæžïŒãå®çžŸã¯èŠæš¡ã®è¿ãæ¡ä»¶ãåç §ããŸããã
- ããŒã ã«ãã£ãŠçç£æ§ã¯éããŸããä»ããŒã ã®å®çžŸã䜿ããšãã¯è£æ£ãèŠããŸã
- æéã¯äººæ°ã§å²ã£ãåçŽèšç®ã§ãã人ãå¢ããã°æ¯äŸããŠçããªãããã§ã¯ãããŸãã
ã©ãã§çŽæããã
ããã§æ³šæãããã®ã¯ãæåŸ
å€ã§çŽæããŠã¯ãããªããšããããšã§ãã
æåŸ
å€ã¯ãäºåäºåã®ç·ããªã®ã§ã11人æã§çŽæãããšãååãããã®ç¢ºçã§è¶
ããŠããŸããŸãã
äºç®ãçŽæã¯çŽ8å²ã®ç¢ºçã§åãŸãç·ïŒäŸã§ã¯12.7人æãçŽ1,270äžåïŒã«çœ®ãã®ããããšèããŠããŸãã
äºæ¥åŽã«ã§ããããš
å¹ ã§èšããããšãã§ãç§ã¯äœã決ããã°ããã®ïŒããšãªããŸããããäºæ¥åŽãæãŠãæã¯å®ã¯ãããããããŸãã
- äºç®ã¯äžåŽã®ç·ã§ç¢ºä¿ãããçŽ8å²ã®ç·ã§ç¢ºä¿ããŠããã°ãå€ãã®å Žåã¯åãŸããäœãã°æ»ããŸã
- 仿§ãæ©ã決ãããäžç¢ºå®æ§ã®ã³ãŒã³ã®ãšããã仿§ã決ãŸãã»ã©å¹ ã¯çãŸããŸã
- ç»é¢ãæžãããåŒãªã®ã§ãç»é¢æ°ãæžãã°éé¡ãå¹ ãäžãããŸã
ãé«ãããå€åŒããŠãã§ã¯ãªããã©ã®ç»é¢ãåããããã©ããå ã«æ±ºããããã§éé¡ãåãããããããåŒãšååžã§è©±ãäžçªã®ã¡ãªããã ãšæããŸãã
å®éã«èããããããè¿ã
ããã£ããã©ã®ãããïŒããšèãããããäŸãã°ãããªè¿ãæ¹ãã§ãããšæããŸãã
ä»ã®è©±ã ãšç»é¢ã20ãããã§ãã
ãããŸã§ã®å®çžŸã ãš1ç»é¢ãããå¹³å0.5人æãªã®ã§ããã¡ã°ããããããªã®ã¯1,000äžåãããã§ãã
ãã ããŸã 決ãŸã£ãŠããªãããšãå€ãã®ã§ã800ã1,800äžåã®å¹ ããããŸãã
å¹³åãããš1,100äžåã8岿¹åãŸãã®ã¯1,300äžå匱ãšèŠãŠããã®ã§ãäºç®ã¯ããã§ç¢ºä¿ããã ãããšå®å¿ã§ãã
仿§ãåºãŸãã°å¹ ã¯çãŸããŸãããç»é¢ãæžããã°éé¡ãäžãããŸãã
ããã§ãããããã1ã€ã®æ°åã§èšã£ãŠãããšèšãããããšããããŸãããããã®ãšãã¯ã
1ã€ã«çµããªãã1,300äžå匱ã§ãã8岿¹ã¯ãã®äžã«åãŸãæ°åã§ãã
1,000äžåãšãçãããããšãã§ããŸããããã®å Žåã¯åå以äžã®ç¢ºçã§è¶ ããŠããŸããŸãã
ãšãã©ã®ç¢ºçã®æ°åãªã®ããæ·»ããŠçããã®ããããšèããŠããŸãã
ãŸãšã
- ããã£ããããšèãã®ã¯ãæ©ã倿ãããããããã®èŠæã«æ ¹æ ã€ãã§å¿ããã®ãåŒãšååž
- æŠç®èŠç©ããã¯ãæ°é à åäœãããã®å·¥æ°ããšããåŒã§åºã
- æ°éã¯ã¹ããŒã¯ãã«ããŒãšææçéã§ããåäœãéžã¶ãå€ãã®å Žåã¯ç»é¢æ°ã§ãããããAPIã®å·¥æ°ã¯å®çžŸã®å¹³åã«åžåãããïŒåªå䟡ãšå€æ§ã®é¢ä¿ãšåãïŒ
- 1ç»é¢ãããã®å·¥æ°ã¯äºæ³ã§ã¯ãªããéå»ã®å®çžŸã®å¹³åã䜿ãïŒåç §ã¯ã©ã¹äºæž¬ïŒããã®ããã«ãç»é¢ã®æ°ãæ¹ã決ããŠå®çžŸãèšé²ãã
- èŠç©ããã¯äºæ³ãªã®ã§ãå®çžŸããäžç¹ãåºããéé¡ã»æéã»ç¢ºçã§äŒãããå®çžŸãååãªãå®çžŸã®ååžããã®ãŸãŸäœ¿ã
- çŽæã¯æåŸ å€ã§ã¯ãªããçŽ8å²ã®ç·ã§ãå¹ ã¯ä»æ§ã決ãŸãã»ã©çãŸããç»é¢ãæžããã°äžãã
åŒãšååžãããã°ãããªãã§ãããªã«ããããã ããšããç©ºäžæŠã§ã¯ãªããã¹ã³ãŒããšäžç¢ºå®æ§ã«ã€ããŠã®è©±ãã§ããããã«ãªããŸãã
äžç¢ºå®äºé ã®å€ãæŠç®ãã§ãŒãºã ãããããæ ¹æ ã®ããåŒãšãååžã§ã®çãæ¹ã倧äºã«ãããããšããã話ã§ããã