
AQUAL is a theory of gravity based on Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND), but using a Lagrangian. It was developed by Jacob Bekenstein and Mordehai Milgrom in their 1984 paper, "Does the missing mass problem signal the breakdown of Newtonian gravity?",[1] as well as a 1986 paper by Milgrom.[2] "AQUAL" stands for "AQUAdratic Lagrangian", stemming from the fact that, in contrast to Newtonian gravity, the proposed Lagrangian is non-quadratic in the potential gradient
|\nabla\Phi|
The gravitational force law obtained from MOND,
m\mu\left(
| a | |
| a0 |
\right)a=
| GMm | |
| r2 |
,
m ≠ M
\mu\left(
| am | |
| a0 |
\right)mam=
| GMm | |
| r2 |
=
| GMm | |
| r2 |
=\mu\left(
| aM | |
| a0 |
\right)MaM
but the third law gives
mam=MaM,
\mu\left(
| am | |
| a0 |
\right)=\mu\left(
| aM | |
| a0 |
\right)
even though
am ≠ aM,
\mu
This problem can be rectified by deriving the force law from a Lagrangian, at the cost of possibly modifying the general form of the force law. Then conservation laws could then be derived from the Lagrangian by the usual means.
The AQUAL Lagrangian is:
\rho\Phi+
| 1 | |
| 8\piG |
| 2 | |
| a | |
| 0 |
F\left(
| |\nabla\Phi|2 | ||||||
|
\right);
this leads to a modified Poisson equation:
\nabla ⋅ \left(\mu\left(
| |\nabla\Phi| | |
| a0 |
\right)\nabla\Phi\right)=4\piG\rho, with \mu(x)=
| dF(x2) | |
| dx |
.
where the predicted acceleration is
-\nabla\Phi=a.
According to Sanders and McGaugh, one problem with AQUAL (or any scalar–tensor theory in which the scalar field enters as a conformal factor multiplying Einstein's metric) is AQUAL's failure to predict the amount of gravitational lensing actually observed in rich clusters of galaxies.[4] AQUAL has been claimed to match observations of wide binary star orbits.[5]