Decanonization Explained
Decanonization or de-canonization (prefix de- ← preposition: down, from, away[1] [2] + ← – list, catalog[3] [4] [5] [6] [7]) is the exclusion of a person's name from a list or catalog of saints; it is the opposite of canonization.[8] [9] Decanonization, the exclusion of a saint's name from the church calendar, was carried out in the Russian Orthodox Church,[10] [11] in the Catholic Church[12] [13] [14] [15] and in the Anglican Church.[16] [17]
Orthodox Church
In the Russian Orthodox Church, the most famous case is the decanonization of the Right-Believing princess Anna of Kashin at the Great Moscow Synod in 1677–1678. The reason for the decanonization was the religious policy of the forcible introduction in Russia of the three fingers sign of the cross, instead of the older two fingers variant.[18] [19] The reforms that began under Alexis Mikhailovich and continued under Peter I and his followers demanded a political and ecclesiastical separation from the previous tradition and national culture, which included the decanonization of persons whose literary or hagiographic works contradicted the new religious policy. The veneration of the famous ecclesiastical writer and translator Maximus the Greek was suspended. Memorial days associated with 21 Russian saints were removed from the Typikon of 1682.[20] During the reign of Peter I, the veneration of the martyrs Anthony, John, and Eustathius, who wore beards and suffered under a clean-shaven pagan knyaz, was stopped.[21] After 1721 the number of new canonizations sharply decreased (only 2 new saints were canonized). In the 18th century there was a decanonization of a number of locally revered saints. However, in the 19th century, church veneration of many locally venerated saints was restored. Hegumen Andronik (Trubachev) believes that the most pernicious were not specific decanonizations, but the very admission of decanonization into church life as a possible norm, a rule implemented due to a change in church policy.[22]
In the 20th century, some of the names of previously decanonized saints were returned to the church calendar. The re-canonization of Anna of Kashin took place in the Russian Orthodox Church in 1909. However, most of the ancient Russian ascetics, whose veneration was terminated during the "struggle against Raskol", remained forgotten.[23]
In 2013, 36 saints, New Martyrs who suffered from repression during the Soviet era, were decanonized. Their names were removed from the 2013 Russian Orthodox Church calendar without explanation.[24] [25] [26] [27] [28]
Catholic Church
There are several examples of decanonization in the Catholic Church throughout the centuries. Among the saints decanonized were Kakwykylla, Wilgefortis, Werner, Liban and a host of others deemed to be legendary figures with no historical veracity. The official position of the church is that persons may still maintain private devotions to these saints, however they are forbidden from public veneration as there is no sufficient evidence for their existence.
On February 14, 1969, Pope Paul VI, through the apostolic letter Mysterii Paschalis, removed the names of a number of saints from the General Roman Calendar, based on a lack of documentary evidence of their lives. These included popes Telephorus, Hyginus, Lucius I, Anicetus, Soter, Caius, Cletus, Eleutherius, Felix I, Victor I and Zephyrinus, as well as saints Dorothy, Maris, Martha, Abachum and Audifax, Faustinus and Jovita, Basilides, Cyrinus, Nabor and Nazarius, Tryphon, Respicius, and Nympha, Sergius and Bacchus, Apuleius, Placid and Companions, Eustace and Companions, Cyprian and Justina, Boniface of Tarsus, Marcellus, Alexius, Symphorosa, the Forty Martyrs of Sebaste, the Seven Holy Brothers, Margaret of Antioch, Catherine of Alexandria, Barbara, and Ursula.[29]
Pope Paul VI also removed Simon of Trent from the Roman Martyrology in 1965.[30]
Anglican Church
On 16 Nov. 1538 Henry VIII issued a proclamation declaring that all images and pictures of Thomas Becket were to be "put down," and all mention of him in calendar and service book to be erased.[31]
In 1966, the Anglican Church excluded Little Saint Hugh of Lincoln from the books of locally revered saints.[32]
In 1859 after Parliament passed the Anniversary Days Observance Act, the commemoration of Charles I (known in the calendar as "Charles, King and Martyr, 1649") was removed, effectively decanonizing Charles.
Challenging the possibility of decanonization
There are members of the clergy and other people in both the Orthodox and Catholic Churches who consider the term "decanonization" to be incorrect. They reject the very possibility of decanonization, regarding canonization as an infallible act that cannot be corrected. They believe that all canonized saints existed, went to Heaven, and remain in Heaven.[33] [34] [35] [36] [37]
Notes and References
- [Walter William Skeat]
- [Charles Annandale]
- https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Голубинский_Е.Е._История_канонизации_святых_в_Русской_Церкви._(1903).djvu&page=10 История канонизации святых в русской церкви
- Ткачев Е. В. Канонизация. Православная энциклопедия. – М. : Церковно-научный центр «Православная энциклопедия», 2012. – Т. XXX. – С. 269–359. – ISBN 978-5-89572-031-8
- CANON // Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume 3; 1913. – P. 255–256. – The name Canon (κανών) means a norm or rule; and it is used for various objects, such as the Canon of Holy Scripture, canons of Councils, the official list of saints' names (whence "canonization"), and the canon or list of clerks who serve a certain church, from which they themselves are called canons (canonici).
- https://www.britannica.com/topic/canonization Canonization Christianity
- [Charles Annandale]
- [James Murray (lexicographer)|James A. H. Murray]
- [Charles Annandale]
- https://books.google.com/books?id=JwN6GIyyIgAC&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PA277 Religion and the Early Modern State Views from China, Russia, and the West./ James D. Tracy, Marguerite Ragnow. 2004 / p. 277
- Making martyrs East & West : canonization in the Catholic and Russian Orthodox churches / Cathy Caridi. – DeKalb, Ill. : NIU press, cop. 2016 / p. 135
- https://books.google.com/books?id=yq8OpvroF5UC&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PA38 Summon's Miscellany of Saints and Sinners// Parminder Summon / 2005 / p. 37
- https://books.google.com/books?id=8LvkDAAAQBAJ&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PA182 Packy Jim Folklore and Worldview on the Irish Border / Ray Cashman. 2016 / p. 182
- https://books.google.com/books?id=Ejeh7dANSc8C&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PT190 Afterlives of the Saints. Stories from the Ends of Faith / Colin Dickey. 2012
- https://books.google.com/books?id=U3gKBAAAQBAJ&dq=de-canonization+saint&pg=PT135 Catholicism Today. An Introduction to the Contemporary Catholic Church / Evyatar Marienberg. 2014
- https://books.google.com/books?id=_zJJtvK2_KsC&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PR16 The Oxford Dictionary of Saints, Fifth Edition Revised / David Farmer, David Hugh Farmer. 2011 / p. xvi
- https://www.uni-due.de/imperia/md/content/perspicuitas/yw1999.pdf Richard Utz. The Medieval Myth of Jewish Ritual Murder: Toward a History of Literary Reception // Edited by Gwendolyn Morgan The Year’s Work in Medievalism. – BOZEMAN, MONTANA: Montana State University, 1999. – Vol. XIV. – p. 22–42.
- [Georgy Fedotov]
- Крест и круг : из истории христианской символики / Б. А. Успенский. – Москва : Языки славянской культур, 2006. – 488 с., [12] л. ил., цв. ил. : цв. ил.; 22 см.; ISBN 5-9551-0108-X (в пер.); ISSN 1727-1630 /с. 90. – Московский собор 1678 г., принявший решение о деканонизации св. Анны Кашинской на том основании, что мощи ее сохранились с двуперстно сложенной рукой / с. 333 – „При патриархе Иоакиме (1675-1690 гг.) были случаи деканонизации святых на том, в частности, основании, что их мощи сохранились с двуперстно сложенной рукой. Так случилось с Анной Кашинской в 1678 г. и с Евфимием Архангелогородским в 1683 г. (см.: Голубинский, 1903, с. 166; Вургафт и Ушаков, 1996, с. 28, 92).“ / с. 365 – Анна Кашинская (в иночестве София) († 1368), жена кн. Михаила Ярославича Тверского; канонизирована в 1649 г., деканонизирована в 1678 г., вновь признана святой в 1909 г.
- http://lib2.pushkinskijdom.ru/Media/Default/PDF/Rusagiografia.%20Т.%20II/28_Наумова.pdf Святость в эпоху Петра Первого
- https://polit.ru/article/2013/02/12/holy_fight/ Борьба за святость
- [w:ru:Андроник (Трубачёв)|игумен Андроник Трубачев]
- https://polit.ru/article/2013/02/12/holy_fight/ Борьба за святость
- https://orthodox-theology.com/media/PDF/1.2018/Mihai-LiviuDinu-Review.pdf Karin Hyldal Christensen. Review THE MAKING OF THE NEW MARTYRS OF RUSSIA Soviet Repression in Orthodox Memory. International Journal of Orthodox Theology 9:1 (2018) / Routledge, 2017
- https://books.google.com/books?id=KZoJEAAAQBAJ&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PT74 Memory Politics and the Russian Civil War Reds Versus Whites / Marlene Laruelle, Margarita Karnysheva. 2020
- http://www.rus-obr.ru/blog/21868 Деканонизация: горькая правда
- https://iz.ru/news/541605 Из календаря РПЦ исчезли некоторые святые
- https://credo.press/140128/ «Инициатива «деканонизации Новомучеников» в РПЦ МП полностью принадлежит игумену Дамаскину (Орловскому)» – доктор исторических наук, агиограф Новомучеников СЕРГЕЙ БЫЧКОВ
- https://archive.org/details/CalendariumRomanum1969/page/n145/mode/2up Calendarium Romanum (1969)
- Kohl . Jeanette . 2018 . A Murder, a Mummy, and a Bust: The Newly Discovered Portrait of Simon of Trent at the Getty . Getty Research Journal . 10 . . 10 . 37–60 . 10.1086/697383 . 978-1-60606-571-6 . 192405280 . Google Books.
- Thomas à Becket . 56 . Norgate . Kate . Kate Norgate. 165-173 . 1.
- https://www.uni-due.de/imperia/md/content/perspicuitas/yw1999.pdf Richard Utz. The Medieval Myth of Jewish Ritual Murder: Toward a History of Literary Reception // Edited by Gwendolyn Morgan The Year’s Work in Medievalism. – BOZEMAN, MONTANA: Montana State University, 1999. – Vol. XIV. – p. 22–42.
- https://books.google.com/books?id=uA38AwAAQBAJ&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PR25 The Comprehensive Dictionary of Patron Saints / Pablo Ricardo Quintana. 2014 / p. XXV
- https://books.google.com/books?id=I8P1DwAAQBAJ&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PT44 Truth Is a Synthesis: Catholic Dogmatic Theology / Mauro Gagliardi. 2020 / p.
- https://books.google.com/books?id=ICvrDQAAQBAJ&dq=decanonization+saint&pg=PT183 The Everything Catholicism Book / Helen Keeler, Susan Grimbly. 2003
- https://www.pravmir.ru/protoierej-vladislav-cypin-v-kanonax-net-dazhe-slova-dekanonizaciya/ Протоиерей Владислав Цыпин: В канонах нет даже слова «деканонизация»
- Ткачев Е. В. Канонизация. Православная энциклопедия. — М. : Церковно-научный центр «Православная энциклопедия», 2012. — Т. XXX. — С. 269—359. — ISBN 978-5-89572-031-8