Pentagram map explained
In mathematics, the pentagram map is a discrete dynamical system acting on polygons in the projective plane. It defines a new polygon by taking the intersections of the "shortest" diagonals, and constructs a new polygon from these intersections. This is a projectively equivariant procedure, hence it descends to the moduli space of polygons and defines another dynamical system (which is also referred to as the pentagram map). It was first introduced by Richard Schwartz in 1992.
The pentagram map on the moduli space is famous for its complete integrability and its interpretation as a cluster algebra.
It admits many generalizations in projective spaces and other settings.
Introduction
Informal definition
On polygons
Initially, the pentagram map was defined for convex polygons (with at least five sides) on the euclidean plane. Given such a polygon
with
sides, one can draw the "shortest
diagonals", meaning the
segments whose endpoints are a
vertex and one of its second neighbors (as in the picture). The intersections of the shortest diagonals are then taken as the vertices of a new
-gon
; this new polygon is the output of the pentagram map.
The same construction can be done on non-convex polygons, but there are several complications. First, some consecutive short diagonals may not intersect, so one must extend the segments to lines. Second, the image
can fail to be a new
-gon because some consecutive vertices could coincide. However, this
generically doesn't happen. Finally, it is possible that two diagonals are
parallel and do not intersect on the
euclidean plane. This is resolved by extending the euclidean plane to the
real projective plane by the addition of a
line at infinity, where the
intersection point lies. Hence, the pentagram map is defined for generic polygons on the real projective plane.
More generally, the construction of the pentagram map is well defined whenever the concepts of lines and their intersections make sense. This is encompassed by the notion of a general projective plane, of which the real projective plane is one example; but the pentagram map can also be considered over other fields, for instance the complex numbers, which give the complex projective plane.
On the moduli space of polygons
Since the pentagram map is defined by taking lines and their intersections, it commutes with any map that sends lines to lines. Such maps are called projective transformations. This allows to identify polygons up to projectivity. This identification gives a quotient space (technically called a moduli space) of classes of polygons. The pentagram map on polygons induces another dynamical system on the moduli space, whose behavior differs quite a lot from the initial one.
Historical elements
The pentagram map for general polygons was introduced in, but the simplest case is the one of pentagons, hence the name "pentagram". Their study goes back to, and .
The pentagram map is similar in spirit to the constructions underlying Desargues's theorem, Pappus's theorem and Poncelet's porism.
Definitions and first properties
Definition of the map
Let
be an integer. A polygon
with
sides, or
-gon, is a tuple of
vertices
lying in some
projective plane
, where the indices are understood
modulo
. The
dimension of the space of
-gons is
.
Suppose that the vertices are in sufficiently general position, meaning that no consecutive triple of points are collinear. Taking the intersection of the two consecutive "shortest" diagonals defines a new pointThis procedure defines a new
-gon
.
The labeling of the indices of
is not
canonical. In most papers, a choice is made at the beginning of the paper and the formulas are tuned accordingly.
. Indeed, each
coordinate of
is given as a
rational function of the coordinates of
, since it is defined as the intersection of lines passing by them. Moreover, the
inverse map is given by taking the intersections
} \cap \overline , which is rational for the same reason.
Moduli space
. Such a transformation
acts on a polygon
by sending it to
. The pentagram map
commutes with this action, and thereby induces another
dynamical system on the
moduli space of projective
equivalence classes of polygons. Its
dimension is
.
Twisted polygons
The pentagram map naturally generalizes on the larger space of twisted polygons. For any integer
, a twisted
-gon
is the data of:
- a bi-infinite sequence of points
in the projective plane (called the vertices),
(called the
monodromy),
such that for any
, the property
is satisfied. The dimension of the space of twisted
-gon is
.
When
, this gives back the initial definition of polygons (which are said to be closed). The space of closed
-gons is of
codimension
in the space of twisted ones.
The action of projective transformations over the space of closed polygons generalizes to the space of twisted ones (the monodromy is changed by conjugation). This provides again a moduli space, of dimension
.
Collapsing of convex polygons
Exponential shrinking
Let
be a closed strictly convex polygon lying on the real plane. One of the first results proved by Richard Schwartz it that its iterates under the pentagram map shrink
exponentially fast to a point. This follows from two facts.
- The image of a strictly convex polygon is contained in its interior, and is also strictly convex.
- There exists a constant
, depending on
, such that for any
, the diameters of the iterates verify the inequality
Hence, by Cantor's intersection theorem, the sequence of polygons collapses toward a point.
The behavior on the moduli space is very different, since the dynamic is recurrent. It is even a quasiperiodic motion, as discussed in the section about integrability.
Coordinates of the limit point
The formula for the limit point is found in . It is a degree 3 polynomial equation that the coordinates of the limit point must satisfy. The coefficients of the polynomial are rational functions in the coordinates of the vertices of the starting polygon. The proof relies on the fact that the limit point must be the eigenline of a certain linear operator of
.
This operator was reinterpreted in as the infinitesimal monodromy of the polygon. The scalling symmetry is used to deform a closed polygon
into a family of twisted ones
with monodromy
. The infinitesimal monodromy is defined to be:
Generalization
The collapsing of polygons may also happen in some generalization of the pentagram map, when considering some specific configurations of polygons in the real plane. The coordinates of the collapse point are given by a formula analogous to the one for the original pentagram map.
Periodic orbits on the moduli space
For some configurations of closed polygons, the iterate of the pentagram map will send
to a projectively equivalent polygon (up to some shift of the indices). This means that, on the moduli space, the orbit of the class of
is
periodic.
Pentagons and hexagons
The two following facts are proved by checking cross-ratio equalities, so they are true for polygons in any projective plane (not just the real one).
The pentagram map
is the identity on the moduli space of
pentagons. The second iterate
is the identity on the space of labeled
hexagons, up to a shift of labeling. This phenomenon doesn't generalize to generic polygons with at least seven sides, for which the motion is
quasi-periodic.
The action of the pentagram map on pentagons and hexagons is similar in spirit to classical configuration theorems in projective geometry such as Pascal's theorem, Desargues's theorem and others.
Generalization
The result about pentagons and hexagons generalizes to some higher pentagram maps in
, for polygons with
or
sides. The proof uses a generalization of the
Gale transform.
Poncelet polygons
A polygon is said to be Poncelet if it is inscribed in a conic and circumbscribed about another one. For a convex Poncelet
-gons
lying on the
real projective plane, the polygon
is projectively equivalent to
. In fact, when
is odd, the converse is also true.
However, this converse statement is no longer true when the polygons are considered over the complex projective plane.
Coordinates for the moduli space
Corner coordinates
Define the cross-ratio of four collinear points to be
| [a,b,c,d]= | (a-b)(c-d) |
| (a-c)(b-d) |
.
The corner invariants are a system of coordinates on the space of twisted polygons, constructed by taking intersections as on the figure. The left and right invariants are respectively defined as the following cross-ratios:
xk:=[vk-2,vk-1,\overline{vk-2vk-1
}\cap\overline,\overline\cap\overline],
}\cap\overline, \overline\cap\overline,v_,v_].
Since the cross-ratio is projective invariant, the sequences
and
associated to a twisted
-gon are
periodic.
When working with
-gon in the projective plane over a
field
, the corner invariants are elements of
. The corner invariants realize an
isomorphism of variety between the moduli space of twisted
-gons and
.
ab-coordinates
There is a second set of coordinates for the moduli space of twisted
-gons defined over a
field
satisfying
, and such that
is not divisible by
.
The vertices
's in the
projective plane
can be
lifted to
vectors
's in the
affine space
so that each consecutive triple of vectors spans a
parallelepiped having
determinant equal to
. This leads to the relation
This bring out an analogy between twisted polygons and solutions of third order linear ordinary differential equations, normalized to have unit Wronskian.
They are linked to the corner coordinates by:
Formulas on the moduli space
As a birational map
The pentagram pentagram map is a birational map on the moduli space, because it can be decomposed as the composition of two birational involutions. The corner invariants change in the following way:
The scaling symmetry
acts on the moduli space in the following way:
Rs ⋅ (x1,...,xn,y1,...,yn)=(sx1,...,sx
yn),
where
is called the scaling action an
is the scaling parameter. This action commutes with the pentagram map on the moduli space (as presented in the previous formulas). This property is called the scaling symmetry, and is instrumental in proving the complete integrability of the dynamic.
is said to have weight
if
Invariant structures
Monodromy invariants
The monodromy invariants, introduced in, are a collection of functions on the moduli space that are invariant under the pentagram map. The simplest example of them are
On=x1x2 … xn, En=y1y2 … yn.
The other monodromy invariants can be retrieved through different points of view: through the scaling symmetry, as
combinatorial objects, or as some
determinants. The one involving scaling symmetry is presented here.
Let
be a
lift of the monodromy of a twisted
-gon. The quantities
| \Omega | |
| | 1= | \operatorname{trace | | 3(M)}{\det(M)}, |
|
)}{\det(M-1)},
are independent of the choice of lift and are invariant under conjugation, so they are well defined for the projective class of the polygon. They are invariant under the pentagram map, since the monodromy matrix doesn't change. Now, the quantities
\tilde{\Omega}1=O
1, \tilde{\Omega}2=OnE
have the same properties, but turn out to be polynomials in the corner invariants. They can be written as
\tilde{\Omega}1=l(\sum
\tilde{\Omega}2=l(\sum
where each
are
homogeneous polynomials respectively of weight
and
(with respect to the rescaling action). The quantities
O1,...,O\lfloor,On,E1,...,E\lfloor,En,
are unchanged by the dynamic, and are called the monodromy invariants. Moreover, they are
algebraically independent.
Polygons on conics
Whenever
is
inscribed on a
conic section, one has
for all
. Moreover, if
is circumscribed about another conic, then its monodromy invariants are characterized by the pair of conics. For such odd-gons, the translation on the
Jacobian variety is restricted to the
Prym variety (which is a half-dimensional torus in the Jacobian).
Poisson bracket
An invariant Poisson bracket on the space of twisted polygons was found in . The monodromy invariants commute with respect to it:for all
.
The Poisson bracket is defined in terms of the corner coordinates by:for all other
The spectral curve
Let
be an element of the
multiplicative group and
be the polygon obtained by applying the rescaling action
on
. A
Lax matrix
is a lift of the monodromy of
satisfying a zero-curvature equation. Then, the spectral function is the bivariate
characteristic polynomialor some renormalization it. The spectral curve is the projective completion of the
affine curve defined by the equation
. It is invariant under the pentagram map, and the monodromy invariants appear as the
coefficients of
. Its
geometric genus is
if
is odd, and
if
is even.
It was first introduced in for his proof of algebraic integrability.
Complete integrability
The pentagram map on the moduli space has been proved to be a completely integrable discrete dynamical system, both in the Arnold-Liouville and the algebro-geometric senses. In any case, this means that the moduli space is almost everywhere foliated by flat tori (or in the algebraic setting, Abelian varieties), where the motion is a translation. This generically makes a quasiperiodic motion.
Arnold–Liouville integrability
The proof of the integrability of the pentagram map on a real twisted polygon was achieved in . This is done by noticing that the monodromy invariants
and
are
Casimir invariants for the bracket, meaning (in this context) that
for all functions
. When
is even, this is also true for the monodromy invariants
and
.
This allows to consider the Casimir level set, where each Casimir has a specified value. Because of Sard's theorem, any generic level set is a smooth manifold. They form a foliation in symplectic leaves, on which the Poisson bracket gives rise to a symplectic form.
Each of these symplectic leaves has an iso-monodromy foliation, namely, a decomposition into the common level sets of the remaining monodromy functions. By using again Sard's theorem, they are generically Lagrangian manifolds. Moreover, they are compact. Since the monodromy invariants Poisson-commute and there are enough of them, the discrete Liouville–Arnold theorem can be applied to prove that the level sets are flat tori over which the dynamic is a translation.
The integrability for real closed polygons was proved in by restricting the Hamiltonian vector fields of monodromy functions to smaller dimensional tori, and showing that enough of them are still independent.
Algebro-geometric integrability
In, it was shown that the pentagram map admits a Lax representation with a spectral parameter, which allows to prove its algebraic-geometric integrability. This means that the space of polygons (either twisted or closed) is parametrized by its spectral data, consisting of its spectral curve, with marked points and a divisor given by a Floquet–Bloch equation. This gives an embedding to the Jacobian variety through the Abel–Jacobi map, where the motion is expressed in term of translation. The previously defined Poisson bracket is also retrieved.
This integrability was generalized in from the field of complex numbers to any algebraically closed field of characteristic different from 2. The translation on a torus is replaced by a translation on an Abelian variety (in fact, a Jacobian variety again).
Dimension of the invariant manifold
For a twisted
-gons, the
dimension of the invariant tori (or Jacobian varieties) is
\begin{cases}n-1&whennisodd,\\
n-2&whenniseven,
\end{cases}
and drops by
for closed
-gons.
Moreover, when
is even, there are two isomorphic Jacobians on which the iterates of the pentagram map alternate. But on each of them, the second iterate of the pentagram is a translation.
Connections to other topics
The Boussinesq equation
The continuous limit of a convex polygon is a parametrized convex curve in the plane. When the time parameter is suitably chosen, the continuous limit of the pentagram map is the classical Boussinesq equation. This equation is a classical example of an integrable partial differential equation.
Here is a description of the geometric action of the Boussinesq equation. Given a locally convex curve
and real numbers
and
, consider the
chord connecting
to
. The
envelope of all these chords is a new curve
. When
is extremely small, the curve
is a good model for the time
evolution of the original curve
under the Boussinesq equation. This construction is also similar to the pentagram map. Moreover, the pentagram invariant bracket is a discretization of a well known invariant Poisson bracket associated to the Boussinesq equation.
Cluster algebras
The pentagram map and some of its generalizations are identified as special cases of cluster algebra. This provides a link with the Poisson–Lie groups, dimer models and other so-called cluster-integrable systems. These methods allow to retrieve the Poisson-bracket and Hamiltonians used to prove complete integrability and provide Lax representations.
Singularity theory
The pentagram map exhibit a property called singularity confinement, which is typical from integrable systems. It states that if a polygon
is
singular for the pentagram map
, then there exists an integer
such that
not singular for the iterate map
.
Moreover, the pentagram map (along with some of its generalizations and other discrete dynamical systems) exhibit the Devron property. This means that if a polygon
is singular for some iterate of the pentagram map
, then it will also be singular for some iterate of the inverse map
.
Generalizations
, under the action of the
projective group
. The pentagram map can be generalized in many ways, and some of them are presented here. Not all of them are integrable. Some are
discretizations of
PDEs from the
KdV hierarchy, seen as higher dimensional version of
Boussinesq or
KP equations. The description of all generalized pentagram maps as
cluster algebras is still an open question.
Polygons in general positions
Let
and
be a twisted polygon of
in
general position.
Short diagonal pentagram maps
The
-th
short diagonal hyperplane
is uniquely defined by passing through the vertices
. Generically, the intersection of
consecutive hyperplanes uniquely defines a new point
Tshvk:=H
\cap
\cap...\cap
.
Doing this for every vertex defines a new twisted polygon. This map, denoted by
, is again projectively equivariant.
Generalized pentagram maps
The previous procedure can be generalized. Let
I=(i1,...,id-1),~J=(j1,...,jd-1)
be two sets of integers, respectively called the jump tuple and the intersection tuple. Define the
-th hyperplane
to be passing through the vertices
. A new point is given by the intersection
TI,Jvk:=H
\cap
\cap...\cap
The map
is called a generalized pentagram map. It is conjectured that the maps
are integrable for any
, but that the general case is not (based on numerical experiments that seem to disprove the diophantine integrability test).
Some of these maps are discretizations of higher dimensional counterpart of the Boussinesq equation in the KdV hierarchy.
Dented pentagram maps
Fix an integer
. Consider the jump tuple
, where the
is at the
-th place, and the intersection tuple
. The dented pentagram map is
. They are proved to be integrable.
For an integer
, the deep dented pentagram map (of depth
)
is the same map as before, but the number
in the definition of
is replaced by
. This kind of pentagram maps are again integrable.
Corrugated polygons
A twisted polygon
lying in
is said to be corrugated if for any
, the vertices
span a projective two-dimensional plane. Such polygons are not in
general position. A new point is defined by
}\cap \overline.
The map
yields a new corrugated polygon. They are completely Liouville-integrable.
In fact, they can retrieved as some dented pentagram map applied on corrugated polygons.
Grassmannians polygons
Let
be integers. The pentagram map can also be generalized to the space of
Grassmannians
, which consists of
-
dimensional linear subspaces of an
-dimensional
vector space. When
, the linear subspaces are lines, which retrieves the definition of
projective spaces
.
A point in
v\in\operatorname{Gr}(m,md)
is represented by an
matrix
such that its columns form a
basis of
. Consider the diagonal
action of the
general linear group
on each column of
. This defines an action on the Grassmannian, even though it's not faithfull. Hence, the polygons of
and their moduli spaces are defined as before, after the change of underlying group.
Depending on the parity of
, one can define linear subspaces spanned by some
's such that taking their intersection generically define a new point of
. This generalization of the pentagram map is integrable in a
noncommutative sense.
Over rings
The pentagram map admits a generalization by considering projective planes over stably finite rings, instead of fields. In particular, this retrieves the pentagram map over Grassmanians. Again, it admits a Lax representation.
References
Notes
Works cited
- The Limit Point of the Pentagram Map and Infinitesimal Monodromy . International Mathematics Research Notices . 2022-03-23 . 1073-7928 . 5383–5397 . 2022 . 7 . 10.1093/imrn/rnaa258 . en . Quinton . Aboud . Anton . Izosimov.
- Integrable Dynamics in Projective Geometry via Dimers and Triple Crossing Diagram Maps on the Cylinder. Symmetry, Integrability and Geometry: Methods and Applications. 2025-06-03. 1815-0659. 10.3842/sigma.2025.040. Niklas Christoph. Affolter. Terrence. George. Sanjay. Ramassamy.
- Berger . Marcel . Marcel Berger . 2005 . Dynamiser la géométrie élémentaire: introduction à des travaux de Richard Schwartz . . fr . 25 . VII . 127–153.
- Bolsinov . Alexey . Matveev . Vladimir S. . Miranda . Eva . Tabachnikov . Serge . 2018-10-28 . Open problems, questions and challenges in finite- dimensional integrable systems . Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences . en . 376 . 2131 . 20170430 . 10.1098/rsta.2017.0430 . 1364-503X . 6158379 . 30224421 . 1804.03737 . 2018RSPTA.37670430B .
- Ueber das ebene Fünfeck. Mathematische Annalen. 1871-09-01. 1432-1807. 476–489. 4. 3. 10.1007/BF01455078. de. A.. Clebsch. Alfred Clebsch.
- The pentagram map on Grassmannians. Annales de l'Institut Fourier. 2019-06-03. 1777-5310. 421–456. 69. 1. 10.5802/aif.3248. en. Raúl. Felipe. Gloria. Marí-Beffa.
- Integrable Systems and Cluster Algebras. 2025-01-01. 294–308. 10.1016/B978-0-323-95703-8.00029-X. en-US. Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics. 2nd. Gekhtman. Michael. Izosimov. Anton . 978-0-323-95706-9 .
- Higher pentagram maps, weighted directed networks, and cluster dynamics. Electronic Research Announcements in Mathematical Sciences. 2012. 1935-9179. 1–17. 19. 10.3934/era.2012.19.1. en. Michael. Gekhtman. Michael. Shapiro. Serge. Tabachnikov. Alek. Vainshtein.
- The pentagram map and Y-patterns. Advances in Mathematics. 2011. 0001-8708. 1019–1045. 227. 2. 10.1016/j.aim.2011.02.018. free. Max. Glick.
- Glick . Max . 2012-12-19 . On singularity confinement for the pentagram map . Journal of Algebraic Combinatorics . 38 . 3 . 597–635 . 10.1007/s10801-012-0417-6 . 0925-9899.
- Glick . Max . 2015 . The Devron property . Journal of Geometry and Physics . 87 . 161–189 . 10.1016/j.geomphys.2014.07.029 . 1312.6881 . 2015JGP....87..161G . 0393-0440.
- The Limit Point of the Pentagram Map. International Mathematics Research Notices. 2020-05-07. 1073-7928. 2818–2831. 2020. 9. 10.1093/imrn/rny110. en. Max. Glick.
- Grammaticos . B. . Ramani . A. . Papageorgiou . V. . 1991-09-30 . Do integrable mappings have the Painlevé property? . Physical Review Letters . 67 . 14 . 1825–1828 . 10.1103/physrevlett.67.1825 . 10044260 . 1991PhRvL..67.1825G . 0031-9007.
- Hand . Leaha . Izosimov . Anton . 2025 . Pentagram maps over rings, Grassmannians, and skewers . Journal of the European Mathematical Society . 2405.06122.
- Izosimov . Anton . 2016 . Pentagrams, inscribed polygons, and Prym varieties . Electronic Research Announcements in Mathematical Sciences . 23 . 25–40 . 10.3934/era.2016.23.004 . 1935-9179.
- Izosimov . Anton . 2022a . The pentagram map, Poncelet polygons, and commuting difference operators . Compositio Mathematica . en . 158 . 5 . 1084–1124 . 10.1112/S0010437X22007345 . 0010-437X.
- Pentagram maps and refactorization in Poisson-Lie groups. Advances in Mathematics. 2022b. 0001-8708. 108476. 404. 10.1016/j.aim.2022.108476. Anton. Izosimov.
- Kasner . Edward . Edward Kasner . 1928 . A Projective Theorem on the Plane Pentagon . The American Mathematical Monthly . 35 . 7 . 352–356 . 10.1080/00029890.1928.11986851 . 0002-9890.
- Integrability of higher pentagram maps. Mathematische Annalen. 2013. 0025-5831. 1005–1047. 357. 3. 10.1007/s00208-013-0922-5. en. Boris. Khesin. Fedor. Soloviev . 1204.0756 .
- Non-integrability vs. integrability in pentagram maps . Journal of Geometry and Physics . 2015a . 275–285 . 87 . 10.1016/j.geomphys.2014.07.027 . en . Boris . Khesin . Fedor . Soloviev . 1404.6221 . 2015JGP....87..275K .
- The geometry of dented pentagram maps . . 2015b . 1435-9855 . 147–179 . 18 . 1 . 10.4171/jems/586 . free . Boris . Khesin . Fedor . Soloviev.
- On Generalizations of the Pentagram Map: Discretizations of AGD Flows. Journal of Nonlinear Science. 2012-12-13. 0938-8974. 303–334. 23. 2. 10.1007/s00332-012-9152-3. Gloria. Marí-Beffa.
- On Integrable Generalizations of the Pentagram Map. International Mathematics Research Notices. 2014-03-24. 1073-7928. 10.1093/imrn/rnu044. en. Gloria. Marí-Beffa.
- The pentagon in the projective plane, with a comment on Napier's rule . Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society . 1945 . 0002-9904 . 985–989 . 51 . 12 . 10.1090/S0002-9904-1945-08488-2 . en . Theodor . Motzkin . Theodore Motzkin.
- Non-commutative integrability of the Grassmann pentagram map. Advances in Mathematics. 2020. 107309. 373. 10.1016/j.aim.2020.107309. free. en. Nicholas. Ovenhouse.
- Quasiperiodic Motion for the Pentagram Map . pdf . Valentin . Ovsienko . Richard Evan . Schwartz . Serge . Sergei Tabachnikov . Tabachnikov . 10821671 . Electronic Research Announcements in Mathematical Sciences . 16 . 2009 . 1–8 . 10.3934/era.2009.16.1 . 0901.1585 . 2009arXiv0901.1585O .
- The Pentagram Map: A Discrete Integrable System. Communications in Mathematical Physics. 2010-10-01. 1432-0916. 409–446. 299. 2. 10.1007/s00220-010-1075-y. en. Valentin. Ovsienko. Richard. Schwartz. Serge. Tabachnikov . 2010CMaPh.299..409O .
- Liouville–Arnold integrability of the pentagram map on closed polygons. Duke Mathematical Journal. 2013-09-15. 0012-7094. 162. 12. 10.1215/00127094-2348219. Valentin. Ovsienko. Richard Evan. Schwartz. Serge. Tabachnikov . 1107.3633 .
- The Pentagram Map . Experimental Mathematics . 1992-01-01 . 1058-6458 . 71–81 . 1 . 1 . 10.1080/10586458.1992.10504248 . Richard . Richard Schwartz (mathematician) . Schwartz . 29 January 2026 .
- The Pentagram Map is Recurrent. Experimental Mathematics. 2001. 1058-6458. 519–528. 10. 4. 10.1080/10586458.2001.10504671. Richard Evan. Schwartz.
- Discrete monodromy, pentagrams, and the method of condensation. Journal of Fixed Point Theory and Applications. 2008-09-01. 1661-7746. 379–409. 3. 2. 10.1007/s11784-008-0079-0. en. Richard Evan. Schwartz.
- Pentagram Spirals. Experimental Mathematics. 2013-10-02. 1058-6458. 384–405. 22. 4. 10.1080/10586458.2013.830582. Richard Evan. Schwartz.
- The pentagram integrals for Poncelet families. Journal of Geometry and Physics. 2015. 432–449. 87. 10.1016/j.geomphys.2014.07.024. en. Richard Evan. Schwartz . 2015JGP....87..432S .
- Book: Schwartz, Richard Evan . The projective heat map . 2017 . American Mathematical Society . 978-1-4704-3514-1 . Mathematical surveys and monographs . Providence, Rhode Island.
- Schwartz . Richard Evan . The Flapping Birds in the Pentagram Zoo . 2025-04-26 . math.DS . 2403.05735.
- Elementary Surprises in Projective Geometry . The Mathematical Intelligencer . 2010 . 0343-6993 . 31–34 . 32 . 3 . 10.1007/s00283-010-9137-8 . en . Richard Evan . Schwartz . Serge . Tabachnikov . 21.11116/0000-0004-24EE-8 .
- The Pentagram Integrals on Inscribed Polygons. The Electronic Journal of Combinatorics. 2011-09-02. 1077-8926. 18. 1. 10.37236/658. Richard Evan. Schwartz. Serge. Tabachnikov . P171 .
- Tabachnikov . Serge . 2019-05-07 . Kasner Meets Poncelet . The Mathematical Intelligencer . 41 . 4 . 56–59 . 10.1007/s00283-019-09897-5 . 1707.09267 . 0343-6993.
- Tupan . Alexandru . 2022-07-03 . Pentagram Configurations for Pentagons and Hexagons . The American Mathematical Monthly . en . 129 . 6 . 554–565 . 10.1080/00029890.2022.2060695 . 0002-9890.
- Pentagram-Type Maps and the Discrete KP Equation. Journal of Nonlinear Science. 2023. 0938-8974. 33. 6. 10.1007/s00332-023-09961-7. en. Bao. Wang . 101 . 2023JNS....33..101W .
- The algebraic dynamics of the pentagram map . Ergodic Theory and Dynamical Systems . 2022-11-25 . 0143-3857 . 3460–3505 . 43 . 10 . 10.1017/etds.2022.82 . Max H. . Weinreich.