Tidal tail explained

A tidal tail is a thin, elongated region of stars and interstellar gas that extends into space from a galaxy. Tidal tails occur as a result of galactic tide forces between interacting galaxies. Examples of galaxies with tidal tails include the Tadpole Galaxy and the Mice Galaxies. Tidal forces can eject a significant amount of a galaxy's gas into the tail; within the Antennae Galaxies, for example, nearly half of the observed gaseous matter is found within the tail structures.[1]

History

The phenomena now referred to as tidal tails were first studied extensively by Fritz Zwicky in 1953.[2] Several astrophysicists expressed their doubts that these extensions could occur solely as the result of tidal forces,[3] [4] including Zwicky himself, who described his own views as "unorthodox".[5] Boris Vorontsov-Velyaminov argued that the tails were too thin and too long to have been produced by gravity alone,[6] as gravity should instead produce broad distortions. However, in 1972, renowned astronomer Alar Toomre modeled close encounters of disk galaxies using three-body (test-particle) simulations and proved that tidal perturbations produce tail structures in interacting systems. that it was indeed tidal forces that were responsible for the tails.[7]

Structure

Morphology

When galaxies interact, the uneven tidal forces between the galaxies can pull matter away from the galactic disks forming tidal tails. Galaxy surveys have found the longest tidal tails can extend farther than 100 kpc from a galaxy, however, most tidal tails surveyed were 10-20 kpc.[8] The shapes of tidal tails can be fit into three broad categories: straight, curved, and plume (formed by the dispersion of tail materials that have gravitated back to the galaxy).[9]

The structure of tidal tails depends on the geometry of encountered galaxies.[10] When the spin of a galactic disk is aligned with the direction of orbital motion, interactions usually generate long and prominent tidal tails. When the disk rotation opposes the orbital motion, tidal features tend to be weaker.[11] Some interacting galaxy pairs have two distinct tails, as is the case for the Antennae Galaxies, while other systems have only one tail. The mass ratio between the interacting galaxies can influence how many tidal tails form and how symmetric they appear.[12] Gravitational torques transmitting during close passages transfer angular momentum outward, making material from the outer disk to move far from the center of the galaxy.[13]

Gas content

Tidal tails (and other tidal features) are found to have a gas content primarily composed of atomic hydrogen (HI),[14] however, regions of molecular hydrogen (H2), traced by CO, are sometimes found in areas of proportionally high densities of HI.[15] Additionally, it is found that tidal tails tend to have low metallicity and dust content, which decrease exponentially at increasing distances from the galaxy.

Stellar composition

Along with the stars pulled out or created by tidal effects, tidal tails have also been found to have active star forming regions with similar properties to those found in galactic disks.[16] Star clusters, including active regions, can be generally found throughout the whole length of the tail. In galaxies with tidal tails, the tails harbor approximately 10% of the galaxy's stellar formation.[17] Overall, roughly 1% of all stellar formation in the known universe occurs within tidal tails.[18]

Observational properties

Most images show that many nearby disk galaxies host extended and faint tidal structures.[19] Identifying the tidal tails can be limited by background modelling and imaging artifacts in data.[20] Tidal tails are a common outcome of gravitational interactions between disk galaxies.[21] Neutral hydrogen can trace tidal debris farther out than the optical light.[22] Star-forming condensations in tidal debris can tend to be tidal dwarf galaxies during the approach.[23]

Tidal tails of clusters

Tidal tails have been observed in clusters as well as galaxies. There have been tidal tails identified around NGC 5466.[24] These tails appear to be roughly 4 degrees in the sky, or 1 kpc in length. There have been other clusters observed with tidal tails as well,[25] [26]

These tidal tails are difficult to measure and different studies show different results. We can most accurately measure tidal tails close to Earth and in the correct orientation.

Notes and References

  1. 10.1086/173373 . Modeling the Spatial Distribution of Star Formation in Interacting Disk Galaxies . Astrophysical Journal . 418 . 82–99 . 1993 . Mihos, Christopher J. . etal . 1993ApJ...418...82M .
  2. Luminous and dark formations of intergalactic matter . Zwicky, Fritz . . April 1953 . 6 . 4 . 7–11 . 10.1063/1.3061224. 1953PhT.....6....7Z .
  3. The Possibility of a Long Lifetime for Intergalactic Arms . Zasov, A. V. . Soviet Astronomy . 11 . 5 . 785 . 1968 . 1968SvA....11..785Z.
  4. Cosmic rays and radio waves as manifestations of a hot universe . Gold, T. . Hoyle, F. . amp . Paris Symposium on Radio Astronomy . . 583–588 . 1959.
  5. Zwicky, Fritz . Intergalactic Bridges . Astronomical Society of the Pacific Leaflets . 9 . 403 . 17–24 . 1963 . 1963ASPL....9...17Z.
  6. Interaction of Multiple Systems . Vorontsov-Velyaminov, B. . Problems of Extra-Galactic Research . 1962 . Macmillan Press . 194–200 . 1962IAUS...15..194V .
  7. Galactic Bridges and Tails . Astrophysical Journal . 178 . 623–666 . 15 December 1972 . Toomre, Alan . Toomre, Juri . amp . 10.1086/151823 . 1972ApJ...178..623T.
  8. Mohamed . Y. H. . Reshetnikov . V. P. . Sotnikova . N. Ya . On the characteristics of tidal structures of interacting galaxies . Astronomy Letters . 2011 . 37 . 10 . 670–678 . 10.1134/S1063773711100045 . en . 1108.6155v1 . 2011AstL...37..670M .
  9. Ren . Jian . Zheng . X Z . Valls-Gabaud . David . Duc . Pierre-Alain . Bell . Eric F . Pan . Zhizheng . Qin . Jianbo . Shi . D D . Qiao . Man . He . Yongqiang . Wen . Run . 2020-10-29 . Long tidal tails in merging galaxies and their implications . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . en . 499 . 3 . 3399–3409 . 10.1093/mnras/staa2985 . free . 0035-8711. 2009.11879 .
  10. Toomre . Alar . Toomre . Juri . 1972ApJ...178..623T Page 623 . 2026-02-18 . The Astrophysical Journal . 1972 . 178 . 623 . 10.1086/151823 . 1972ApJ...178..623T .
  11. Rudnick . Gregory . Rix . Hans-Walter . September 1998 . Lopsidedness in Early-Type Disk Galaxies . The Astronomical Journal . 116 . 3 . 1163–1168 . 10.1086/300518 . astro-ph/9805316 . 1998AJ....116.1163R . 0004-6256.
  12. Duc . Pierre-Alain . Tidal dwarf galaxies . 1997-11-21 . Mirabel . Felix . The Messenger . 89 . 14 . astro-ph/9711253 . 1997Msngr..89...14D .
  13. Bournaud . Frederic . Star formation and structure formation in galaxy collisions . 2009-09-16 . astro-ph.CO . 0909.1812 .
  14. Combes . F. . Extended gas in interacting systems . 1997-11-03 . astro-ph/9711006 .
  15. Braine . Jonathan . Lisenfeld . Ute . Due . Pierre-Alain . Leon . Stéphane . 2000-02-24 . Formation of molecular gas in the tidal debris of violent galaxy–galaxy interactions . Nature . en . 403 . 6772 . 867–869 . 10.1038/35002521 . 10706277 . 2000Natur.403..867B . 1476-4687. subscription .
  16. Rodruck . Michael . Charlton . Jane . Borthakur . Sanchayeeta . Chitre . Aparna . Durrell . Patrick R . Elmegreen . Debra . English . Jayanne . Gallagher . Sarah C . Gronwall . Caryl . Knierman . Karen . Konstantopoulos . Iraklis . Li . Yuexing . Maji . Moupiya . Mullan . Brendan . Trancho . Gelys . 2023-09-29 . Star clusters in tidal debris . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society . en . 526 . 2 . 2341–2364 . 10.1093/mnras/stad2886 . free . 0035-8711.
  17. Remarkable Disk and Off-Nuclear Starburst Activity in the Tadpole Galaxy as revealed by the Spitzer Space Telescope . Jarrett, T. H. . etal . Astronomical Journal . 131 . 1 . 261–281 . 2006 . 10.1086/498414 . 2006AJ....131..261J. astro-ph/0510788 .
  18. Web site: 'Shot in the Dark' Star Explosion Stuns Astronomers . NASA Goddard Flight Center . 18 December 2007 . Naeye, Robert . 18 June 2010.
  19. Martínez-Delgado . David . Gabany . R. Jay . Crawford . Ken . Zibetti . Stefano . Majewski . Steven R. . Rix . Hans-Walter . Fliri . Jürgen . Carballo-Bello . Julio A. . Bardalez-Gagliuffi . Daniella C. . Peñarrubia . Jorge . Chonis . Taylor S. . Madore . Barry . Trujillo . Ignacio . Schirmer . Mischa . McDavid . David A. . 2010-09-07 . STELLAR TIDAL STREAMS IN SPIRAL GALAXIES OF THE LOCAL VOLUME: A PILOT SURVEY WITH MODEST APERTURE TELESCOPES . The Astronomical Journal . 140 . 4 . 962–967 . 10.1088/0004-6256/140/4/962 . 0004-6256. 1003.4860 .
  20. Sola . Elisabeth . Duc . Pierre-Alain . Richards . Felix . Paiement . Adeline . Urbano . Mathias . Klehammer . Julie . Bílek . Michal . Cuillandre . Jean-Charles . Gwyn . Stephen . McConnachie . Alan . 2022-06-01 . Characterization of low surface brightness structures in annotated deep images . Astronomy & Astrophysics . en . 662 . A124 . 10.1051/0004-6361/202142675 . 0004-6361. 2203.03973 .
  21. Barnes . Joshua E. . Hernquist . Lars . 1992-09-01 . Dynamics of Interacting Galaxies . Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics . en . 30 . 705–742 . 10.1146/annurev.aa.30.090192.003421 . 0066-4146. subscription .
  22. Hibbard . J. E. . van Gorkom . J. H. . HI, HII, and R-Band Observations of a Galactic Merger Sequence . The Astronomical Journal . en . 111 . 655 . 10.1086/117815 . 0004-6256. astro-ph/9512035 .
  23. Barnes . Joshua E. . Hernquist . Lars . 1992-09-01 . Dynamics of Interacting Galaxies . Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics . en . 30 . 705–742 . 10.1146/annurev.aa.30.090192.003421 . 0066-4146. subscription .
  24. Dietrich . J. P. . February 2008 . The Importance of Being First: Position Dependent Citation Rates on arXiv:astro-ph . Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific . 120 . 864 . 224–228 . 10.1086/527522 . 0712.1037 . 2008PASP..120..224D . 0004-6280.
  25. Piatti . Andrés E. . Carballo-Bello . Julio A. . 2020-05-01 . The tidal tails of Milky Way globular clusters . Astronomy & Astrophysics . en . 637 . L2 . 10.1051/0004-6361/202037994 . 2004.11747 . 2020A&A...637L...2P . 0004-6361.
  26. Zhang . Jiajun . Zhao . Jingkun . Oswalt . Terry D. . Fang . Xiangsong . Zhao . Gang . Liang . Xilong . Ye . Xianhao . Zhong . Jing . 2019-12-12 . Stellar Chromospheric Activity and Age Relation from Open Clusters in the LAMOST Survey . The Astrophysical Journal . 887 . 1 . 84 . 1909.13520 . 2019ApJ...887...84Z . 10.3847/1538-4357/ab4efe . 0004-637X . free.
  27. 2406.18767 . 10.1051/0004-6361/202449828 . Tidal tails of open clusters . 2024 . Kos . Janez . Astronomy & Astrophysics . 691 . A28 . 2024A&A...691A..28K .
  28. 2501.17225 . Risbud . Dhanraj . Jadhav . Vikrant V. . Kroupa . Pavel . Tidal tails of nearby open clusters I. Mapping with Gaia DR3 . Astronomy and Astrophysics . 2025 . 694 . 10.1051/0004-6361/202453302 . 2025A&A...694A.258R .