If there is one place on earth where
economic inequality is most unabashedly in-you-face within the confinements of
four walls and under one roof, this place would indubitably be the airplane.
This is nothing new. Air travel has always been about the haves and have-nots. If you've got the dough, you whizz pass check-in and security on a red carpet, sip on champagne in the exclusive airline lounge, then get pampered with caviar and premium service in the privacy and luxury of a First Class suite until you reach your destination waking up in silk. For the less well-off, air travel means claustrophobia, numb rumps, armrest wars, dog food, and long lines for the filthy loo. And for the even less moneyed? They don't travel at all.
The airplane is a replica of a highly stratified society in a nut shell - a perfect cross section of the socioeconomic pyramid constituting of the powerful Elite (the Top Crust), the Bourgeoisie (aka. Wannabes) and, underneath them all, an overwhelmingly large base of Proletarians (the mass working class). Take a stroll from nose to tail on any given flights dispatched between Hong Kong and Dubai, and no sooner will you see the economic divide between the haves and have-nots - with the front end taken up by loaded Arab families (probably with their hands on oil reserves), affluent Asian holidaymakers, and then - with merely a curtain in between, throngs of migrant workers and contract laborers at the rear trying to make ends meet.
What makes an airplane distinct from society is the extent of this socioeconomic disparity so shamelessly conspicuous that it verges on the offensive. As passengers traveling in coach straddle towards their cramped quarters in the back, they are forced to first marvel at the opulence of First and Business Class, only to gawk with lust and envy at something so close yet so distant and then silently lower their heads in submission to their humble destiny. Like a wide-eyed dreamer wandering in a Hermès boutique, you can touch, feel, and dream - but snap back into harsh reality once you find out the almighty price.
Sure enough, a city has readily distinguishable neighborhoods separating the rich and the poor, but few are as concretely demarcated and as boldly segregating as the curtains that erect tangible boundaries between the haves and the have-nots on an aeroplane.
None is as illustrative as my
recent flight operated from Surabaya, Indonesia. With only days until the Eid
al-Fitr, an important Muslim holiday marking the end of the Ramadan, hordes of
the powerful and the elite are fluxing out of the country for vacation
overseas. The second-largest city in Indonesia, Surabaya boasts a population
with an ever widening economic gap, where Indonesians of Chinese descent
invariably make up the Top Crust.
Indonesian-Chinese in Surabaya can be very wealthy. And when I say wealthy, I mean seriously wealthy. Think fair-skinned tai-tais with characteristically high, puffy hairdos, heavy makeup, and branded handbags. Hence the reproduction of Surabaya society on the airplane takes on an extra racial dimension - where the darker masses (mostly migrant domestic helpers and some middle class) are filling the back, the fairness-obsessed Indonesian-Chinese occupy the front end.
So what is it exactly that makes this group of high-spending travelers so unforgettable?
This is nothing new. Air travel has always been about the haves and have-nots. If you've got the dough, you whizz pass check-in and security on a red carpet, sip on champagne in the exclusive airline lounge, then get pampered with caviar and premium service in the privacy and luxury of a First Class suite until you reach your destination waking up in silk. For the less well-off, air travel means claustrophobia, numb rumps, armrest wars, dog food, and long lines for the filthy loo. And for the even less moneyed? They don't travel at all.
The airplane is a replica of a highly stratified society in a nut shell - a perfect cross section of the socioeconomic pyramid constituting of the powerful Elite (the Top Crust), the Bourgeoisie (aka. Wannabes) and, underneath them all, an overwhelmingly large base of Proletarians (the mass working class). Take a stroll from nose to tail on any given flights dispatched between Hong Kong and Dubai, and no sooner will you see the economic divide between the haves and have-nots - with the front end taken up by loaded Arab families (probably with their hands on oil reserves), affluent Asian holidaymakers, and then - with merely a curtain in between, throngs of migrant workers and contract laborers at the rear trying to make ends meet.
What makes an airplane distinct from society is the extent of this socioeconomic disparity so shamelessly conspicuous that it verges on the offensive. As passengers traveling in coach straddle towards their cramped quarters in the back, they are forced to first marvel at the opulence of First and Business Class, only to gawk with lust and envy at something so close yet so distant and then silently lower their heads in submission to their humble destiny. Like a wide-eyed dreamer wandering in a Hermès boutique, you can touch, feel, and dream - but snap back into harsh reality once you find out the almighty price.
Sure enough, a city has readily distinguishable neighborhoods separating the rich and the poor, but few are as concretely demarcated and as boldly segregating as the curtains that erect tangible boundaries between the haves and the have-nots on an aeroplane.
| A grandiose mosque in Surabaya |
Indonesian-Chinese in Surabaya can be very wealthy. And when I say wealthy, I mean seriously wealthy. Think fair-skinned tai-tais with characteristically high, puffy hairdos, heavy makeup, and branded handbags. Hence the reproduction of Surabaya society on the airplane takes on an extra racial dimension - where the darker masses (mostly migrant domestic helpers and some middle class) are filling the back, the fairness-obsessed Indonesian-Chinese occupy the front end.
So what is it exactly that makes this group of high-spending travelers so unforgettable?
Their accessories. The universal Asian symbol of status.
Literally, I thought I have stepped into a private underground showroom of Hermès.
Kelly, Birkin, Kelly, oh, yet
another Birkin. Okay, more like a Hermès “wonderland” -
since in reality it will require serious charm and winning the lottery to even
cajole a Herbag out of the staunch
gatekeepers of this prestigious marque.
12 H - an exceptionally rare turquoise calf leather; 18 K - an equally coveted baby blue. Of course, Mrs. So-and-so seated in 12 H protects the lush leather handles by wrapping them with a signature Hermès silk scarf. And Mme. So-and-so in 18 K keeps her precious tote in a canvas bag before gently placing it into the overhead bin. But the real show-stopper really is 14 G - crafted from the most valuable saltwater crocodile hide - which Ms. So-and-so can care less about tossing into the overhead compartment. This epitome of a luxury, one-of-a-kind, hand-crafted bag instantly puts a neighboring Gucci to shame.
… And what about the lonesome Longchamp? Save it for the groceries.
"Check out that overhead compartment," my good friend and colleague snickers, his head motioning towards the treasure chest, "there's hundreds of thousands dollar worth of goods in there alone." It's true. Within a mere half hour during boarding, I have handled enough Hermès bags to pay off a mortgage.
Half of the passengers in this cabin are related one way or another, and as families they are traveling altogether on Business Class from Surabaya via Hong Kong for a holiday in New York and San Francisco. With each Business Class round-trip ticket between Indonesia and the US valuing at the fifth digit in US Dollar, it takes no genius to calculate the extent of damage a vacation as such causes to a family's savings.
For the Have-nots, it is beyond a lifetime's worth of slaving and savings. For the Haves, it might just be another Hermès in the closet.
[Any thought or comments? Share with me!]
12 H - an exceptionally rare turquoise calf leather; 18 K - an equally coveted baby blue. Of course, Mrs. So-and-so seated in 12 H protects the lush leather handles by wrapping them with a signature Hermès silk scarf. And Mme. So-and-so in 18 K keeps her precious tote in a canvas bag before gently placing it into the overhead bin. But the real show-stopper really is 14 G - crafted from the most valuable saltwater crocodile hide - which Ms. So-and-so can care less about tossing into the overhead compartment. This epitome of a luxury, one-of-a-kind, hand-crafted bag instantly puts a neighboring Gucci to shame.
… And what about the lonesome Longchamp? Save it for the groceries.
| Morning traffic in Surabaya, a city of extremes |
Half of the passengers in this cabin are related one way or another, and as families they are traveling altogether on Business Class from Surabaya via Hong Kong for a holiday in New York and San Francisco. With each Business Class round-trip ticket between Indonesia and the US valuing at the fifth digit in US Dollar, it takes no genius to calculate the extent of damage a vacation as such causes to a family's savings.
For the Have-nots, it is beyond a lifetime's worth of slaving and savings. For the Haves, it might just be another Hermès in the closet.
[Any thought or comments? Share with me!]