You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Just reposting my last 2 comments on #349 for visibility since it already got merged
Currently there's no indication that the diagram would change upon selecting another option. How about something like this? 2 large buttons side-to-side.
Furthermore, a nitpick but maybe there isn't a reason to add the subtitle explaining why euphonica needs it, perhaps put the explanation in a tooltip behind a help icon (?) instead
Thanks for the suggestion. It does look better, though there's a rather dumb limitation regarding aspect ratio: I need to use GtkImages to display those SVGs and have them be accent-coloured (i.e. symbolic-style icons), but rendering them that way forces them to have 1:1 ratios, so the above layout will necessarily have to show a lot of left-right paddings, making the whole thing rather wide.
While there is no indication that the image would change, I'm expecting the user to just idle-click back and forth between the options and see them anyway, so I don't think it's a severe intuitiveness issue.
As for the help tooltip thing, that does the trick indeed, but maybe we can implement it as an accordion of sorts, collapsed by default? It'll be bigger and more inviting to the inclined user than a small question mark.
but rendering them that way forces them to have 1:1 ratios, so the above layout will necessarily have to show a lot of left-right paddings, making the whole thing rather wide.
Sorry, but I don't know what you mean. I just opened #355 and it works fine
As for the help tooltip thing, that does the trick indeed, but maybe we can implement it as an accordion of sorts, collapsed by default?
Activity
htkhiem commentedon Sep 1, 2026
Thanks for the suggestion. It does look better, though there's a rather dumb limitation regarding aspect ratio: I need to use GtkImages to display those SVGs and have them be accent-coloured (i.e. symbolic-style icons), but rendering them that way forces them to have 1:1 ratios, so the above layout will necessarily have to show a lot of left-right paddings, making the whole thing rather wide.
While there is no indication that the image would change, I'm expecting the user to just idle-click back and forth between the options and see them anyway, so I don't think it's a severe intuitiveness issue.
As for the help tooltip thing, that does the trick indeed, but maybe we can implement it as an accordion of sorts, collapsed by default? It'll be bigger and more inviting to the inclined user than a small question mark.
aaravrav commentedon Sep 3, 2026
Sorry, but I don't know what you mean. I just opened #355 and it works fine
Sure